No-Shows, Deposits and Guest Policies

Corkage, Cake-Cutting and Outside Food Policies

How to set and state corkage and cake-cutting fees, what state liquor rules mean for BYOB, and how to handle outside food and allergens safely.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. Why these policies need writing down
  2. Start with your state's alcohol rules
  3. Setting a corkage fee where it is allowed
  4. Cake-cutting and outside desserts
  5. Outside food and allergens
  6. Policy wording
  7. Questions to ask at booking
  8. Exceptions
  9. Example: a wine bar's two-line policy
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
No-Shows, Deposits and Guest Policies: Corkage, Cake-Cutting and Outside Food PoliciesArticle coverNO-SHOWS, DEPOSITS AND GUEST POLICIESCorkage, Cake-Cuttingand Outside FoodPoliciesAva for RestaurantsInsightsNo-Shows, Deposits and Guest Policies: Corkage, Cake-Cutting and Outside Food PoliciesArticle coverNO-SHOWS, DEPOSITS AND GUEST POLICIESCorkage, Cake-Cuttingand Outside FoodPoliciesAva for Restaurants

Key takeaways

  • BYOB rules are set by each state, and sometimes by local ordinance, and they differ sharply[1][2].
  • Pennsylvania guidance says establishments may set house rules on BYOB and may charge corkage[1]; New Jersey bars unlicensed restaurants from charging corkage[2].
  • Treat an outside cake as an allergen question: the major allergens account for 90% of US food allergies[3].
  • State every fee where guests book and on the menu, and decide exceptions before the guest arrives.

Why these policies need writing down

Guests bring things to restaurants for good reasons: a bottle saved for an anniversary, a birthday cake from the family's favorite bakery, a special dessert for a child with allergies. Each request lands on a host or server who has to decide on the spot whether it is allowed, what it costs and who is responsible if something goes wrong. Without a written policy, the answer depends on who is working, and the guest who was charged a corkage fee last week and not this week notices.

Writing it down protects three things: your license, because alcohol rules are strict and the restaurant carries the risk; your guests' safety, because outside food bypasses your allergen controls; and your margins, because opening, pouring, plating and cleaning up after outside items takes staff time and glassware. A short policy, stated at booking and on the menu, settles all three.

Start with your state's alcohol rules

Whether guests may bring alcohol, and whether you may charge for it, depends on state law and sometimes on local ordinance. Two neighboring states show how different the answers can be.

Pennsylvania's Liquor Control Board guidance says nothing in the state's Liquor Code or the Board's regulations prohibits an individual from bringing their own legally purchased alcohol into an establishment, whether or not it holds a license[1]. Establishments may set their own house rules allowing or banning BYOB and may, but are not required to, charge a corkage fee[1]. Licensees remain strictly liable for violations on their premises and must make sure alcohol is not served to minors or visibly intoxicated patrons, and the guidance suggests asking guests to keep receipts showing the alcohol was lawfully bought[1].

New Jersey takes a different line for unlicensed restaurants. Unless a local ordinance prohibits it, customers may be allowed to bring and consume only wine and beer; the restaurant may supply glasses and ice but may not impose a cover, corkage or service charge, may never permit spirits, and may not advertise that BYOB is allowed[2]. The owner also may not allow drinking during hours when licensees in that municipality cannot sell, or by anyone under 21 or apparently intoxicated[2].

Two state approaches to BYOB (summary; check current rules and local ordinances)
QuestionPennsylvania (PLCB guidance)New Jersey (unlicensed restaurants)
Can guests bring alcohol?Yes, if legally procured, subject to the establishment's house rulesWine and beer only, unless a local ordinance prohibits it
Can the restaurant charge corkage?Yes, it may but is not required toNo cover, corkage or service charge
SpiritsNot restricted by the guidance summarized hereNever permitted
Advertising BYOBNot addressed in the guidance summarized hereNot allowed
Who carries the riskLicensees are strictly liable for violations on premisesThe owner must enforce hours, age and intoxication limits

Other states have their own rules, and some do not allow licensed premises to permit outside alcohol at all. Check with your state alcohol regulator and your city before writing a corkage policy, and recheck when your license changes.

Setting a corkage fee where it is allowed

  • Decide what it covers: opening, glassware, chilling, pouring and the bottle's share of service time.
  • Charge per bottle, with a limit per table, such as two bottles.
  • Do not accept bottles already on your list, or charge a higher fee for them; guests bringing your own list wine is a different conversation.
  • Consider waiving one corkage fee for each bottle bought from your list.
  • Set a separate rule for large formats and for spirits, or exclude spirits entirely.
  • Apply your normal service rules: staff check ID, pour responsibly and stop service when needed, exactly as for your own wine.
  • Publish the fee on the wine list, the website and the booking page.

The fee should feel like fair payment for service, not a deterrent. If you would rather not allow outside wine at all, say so plainly rather than setting a fee so high that it reads as a refusal in disguise.

Tell the server about the bottle when the party is seated, not when it is opened, so the fee and any limit are mentioned once, calmly, at the start. Note the fee on the check as its own line, labeled Corkage, so the guest can see exactly what they paid for.

Cake-cutting and outside desserts

Cake-cutting fees, sometimes called plating fees, pay for the plates, cutlery, staff time and the dessert your kitchen will not sell to that table. A per-guest fee is the most common approach and the easiest to explain. Some restaurants waive it for children's birthdays or for parties that order a set menu.

  • Ask at booking whether the party is bringing a cake, and from where.
  • Say who will cut and serve it, and whether candles or sparklers are allowed.
  • Store it out of the kitchen's production area, labeled with the guest's name.
  • Serve it as it came: do not add your own sauces or garnishes to an outside cake.
  • Offer to box leftovers, and say whether there is a charge for the box.

Outside food and allergens

Outside food is the part of these policies that matters most for safety. When the eight major allergens were written into federal law, they accounted for 90% of food allergies and serious allergic reactions in the US[3], and sesame was added as the ninth major allergen, with FDA requirements applying from January 1, 2023[4]. Your kitchen controls those allergens for its own dishes. It cannot vouch for a cake made elsewhere.

Share of US food allergies covered by the eight major allergensAt the time federal allergen labeling law passed; sesame has since been added as a ninth
Share of US food allergies covered by the eight major allergensDonut chart. Eight major allergens: 90%.Eight major allergens: 90%90%
  • Eight major allergens 90%

Source: US Food and Drug Administration, 2004[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Eight major allergens90%

Health rules also play a part. Most state and local food codes build on the FDA Food Code, which agencies adopt and adapt[5], so ask your inspector how food brought in by guests should be handled in your jurisdiction, especially whether staff may cut and plate it. A clear policy keeps outside items separate from your kitchen, makes the guest responsible for its ingredients, and makes sure servers never describe an outside item as safe for an allergy.

Policy wording

Example policy: “Bringing a special bottle? Corkage is a set fee per 750 ml bottle, up to two bottles per table, waived for each bottle you buy from our list. We don’t accept bottles that are on our list. Celebrating? You’re welcome to bring a cake; we’ll plate it for a small fee per guest. Please tell us when you book. We can’t check the ingredients of food made outside our kitchen, so please let us know about any allergies in your party.”

Adapt the wording to your state's rules. In a state where corkage is not allowed, drop the fee and keep the limits and the allergy line. In a state or city that bans outside alcohol for your license type, say so in the first sentence so guests do not arrive with a bottle.

Questions to ask at booking

  1. Are you celebrating anything with us?
  2. Will you be bringing a cake, dessert or wine?
  3. Where is the cake from, and does anyone in the party have food allergies?
  4. Would you like us to bring it out with candles, and at what point in the meal?
  5. Shall I note the corkage or plating fee so there are no surprises?

Note the answers on the booking, and repeat them in the confirmation message. A host who knows a cake is coming can plan fridge space and timing; a server who reads the note can raise the allergy question before anyone eats.

Exceptions

Handling common outside food and drink requests
SituationSuggested handling
Child with severe allergies brings their own safe dessertAllow it, keep it separate, and waive the plating fee
Guest arrives with a cake not mentioned at bookingAccept it if you can store it; apply the stated fee
Guest brings spirits where you only allow winePolitely decline and offer to hold the bottle until they leave
Guest brings a bottle that is on your listExplain the rule and offer the list bottle at the table
Large party brings several bottlesApply the per-table limit, or agree terms in advance for events

Example: a wine bar's two-line policy

Example: a fictional licensed wine bar in a state that allows BYOB at the establishment's discretion sets a simple rule: corkage per bottle, two bottles per table, waived when the table buys a bottle from the list, and no bottles that appear on the list. Cakes are welcome with a per-guest plating fee, waived for children's birthdays. The policy is printed at the bottom of the wine list and on the booking page, and hosts ask the cake question on every booking that mentions a celebration. Disputes at the table disappear, because every guest heard the same rule before arriving.

Frequently asked questions

Is it legal to charge a corkage fee?

It depends on your state and license. Pennsylvania guidance says establishments may charge corkage, while New Jersey bars unlicensed restaurants from charging corkage on BYOB wine and beer. Check your state alcohol regulator and local rules.

Can a restaurant refuse outside cakes?

Generally yes, as a house rule, unless a local rule says otherwise. Many restaurants allow them with a plating fee and a clear note that they cannot vouch for outside ingredients.

Should staff cut an outside cake?

Ask your local health inspector how outside food should be handled. Where it is allowed, cut and plate it away from the production line, serve it as it came, and never describe it as allergy-safe.

References

  1. Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board (2017). Bring Your Own Alcoholic Beverage (BYOB) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. New Jersey Division of Alcoholic Beverage Control (2020). Alcoholic Beverage Control Handbook for Retail Licensees (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. US Food and Drug Administration (2004). Food Allergies (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. US Food and Drug Administration (2023). Food Allergies (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. US Food and Drug Administration (2026). FDA Food Code (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo