Key takeaways
- Since July 1, 2024, California's hidden fees law requires most advertised prices to include all mandatory fees[1].
- Restaurant and bar mandatory fees are exempt only when clearly and conspicuously displayed wherever prices are shown[1].
- Optional fees and government taxes need not be in the advertised price, and an avoidable card fee is generally not mandatory[1].
- Channel prices differ: 66% of full-service operators charge more on third-party apps[2], so check every channel's price display.
What the law says, in plain terms
California's Honest Pricing Law, also called the Hidden Fees Statute, took effect on July 1, 2024. SB 478 makes it illegal for most businesses to advertise or list a price that does not include all required fees, and SB 1524 later amended it[1]. The Attorney General's summary puts the goal in one line: the price a Californian sees should be the price they pay[1].
The core rule bars advertising, displaying or offering a price that does not include all mandatory fees or charges, other than government-imposed taxes or fees and reasonable shipping costs[1]. Businesses can still break down what is inside a total price; what they cannot do, in general, is show a lower price and add the mandatory part later. This guide summarizes the Attorney General's published guidance; it is not legal advice, and you should confirm your own situation with counsel.
The restaurant exemption
Restaurants, bars and some other food vendors have a specific carve-out. Their mandatory fees are exempt from SB 478's requirements so long as the fee is clearly and conspicuously displayed wherever prices are shown[1]. So a restaurant may keep a separate 18 percent service charge, rather than folding it into each item price, but only if the fee is shown clearly everywhere a price appears.
Wherever prices are shown is the demanding part. In practice it covers far more than the printed dinner menu:
- Printed menus, QR menus and table cards.
- Your website menu and your own online ordering pages.
- Menus you publish on third-party ordering and delivery listings.
- Specials boards, bar menus, happy hour signs and counter displays.
- Social posts and ads that mention a price.
- Event and catering menus, quotes and private dining packages.
The guidance does not define clearly and conspicuously in detail. A cautious reading is that the fee should sit next to the prices, in type guests will notice, rather than in a footnote, the terms page or the final screen of an online checkout.
What does not have to be in the price
- Fees for optional services or features, such as an optional add-on the guest chooses[1].
- Taxes and fees the government imposes on the transaction, such as sales tax[1].
- Fees that depend on the guest's later conduct, which the guidance describes as not mandatory[1].
- Credit card processing fees the guest can avoid by paying another way, such as cash. If you accept only cards, the guidance says the card fee becomes mandatory and must be included[1].
Card surcharges also have to meet card network rules and federal and state law on surcharging, which are separate from SB 478. See credit card surcharges by state before adding one.
What the guidance rules out
For most businesses, the Attorney General's guidance says no to three common practices: advertising one price and adding a variable service fee later in the transaction, disclosing extra required fees just before the consumer finalizes the purchase, and listing a price with a separate statement that an additional percentage fee will apply[1]. For restaurants, each of those answers is followed by the same exemption: mandatory restaurant fees are allowed when clearly and conspicuously displayed wherever prices are shown[1]. The test for a restaurant is therefore not whether the fee is separate, but whether it is visible everywhere the prices are.
Channel-by-channel check
| Channel | What to check |
|---|---|
| Dine-in menu | Fee line at the top of every page, near the prices, in readable type |
| QR menu | Fee shown on the first screen and on each section, not only in a footer |
| Your online ordering | Fee shown on item prices or menu headers before the cart |
| Third-party menus you manage | Fee or adjusted prices shown in the listing itself |
| Specials board and bar signs | Fee line wherever a price is chalked or printed |
| Ads and social posts with prices | Fee stated with the price, or the all-in price shown |
| Catering and event quotes | Service charges and fees listed with the menu prices |
| The check | Fee shown as its own labeled line |
Wording that meets the display test
Example menu header: “An 18% service charge is added to all dine-in checks. It is shared by our kitchen and floor team as part of their pay. Additional tips are optional.”
- Example for online ordering: “Menu prices include all fees.” Or, if you keep a fee: “A 5% service charge applies to online orders and is shown with each item price.”
- Example happy hour sign: “4 to 6 p.m., draft beer 6 dollars. 18% service charge applies.”
- Example for event quotes: list the service charge on the same page as the per-person menu price, not in the terms.
Service charge, tip or price?
A California restaurant that keeps a separate fee still has to decide what it is. The IRS treats automatic charges on the check, such as large-party gratuities, as service charges, reported as non-tip wages when paid to staff[3]. That affects payroll and what you can promise guests about where the money goes. If any part of the charge is kept by the business, say so, or describe what the charge funds, rather than implying it is a tip for the server.
Many restaurants have chosen to fold fees into menu prices instead. Full-service meal prices rose 3.8% nationally in the 12 months to September 2026[4], and a single all-in price is the simplest way to meet the display test everywhere at once.
Delivery apps and other channels
Delivery platforms are covered by the law in their own right: the guidance says food delivery platforms advertising their own delivery service must advertise its full, all-in price[1]. Restaurants still control their own menu prices on those platforms, and most charge more there. In a 2026 National Restaurant Association survey, 83% of limited-service and 66% of full-service operators said they charge more for items ordered through a third-party provider than for dine-in or takeout[2]. Different prices on different channels are allowed; what matters is that each channel shows its own true price and any mandatory restaurant fee.
Source: National Restaurant Association, 2026[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Limited-service operators | 83% |
| Full-service operators | 66% |
A quarterly audit
List every place a price appears
Menus, QR pages, website, ordering, third-party listings, signs, ads and quotes.
Check each for the fee
Is the fee visible next to the prices, in readable type, before the guest orders?
Fix the gaps
Update the source files and ask platforms to update listings you cannot edit directly.
Check the check
Make sure the POS prints the fee as its own labeled line with the same name used on menus.
Brief staff
Give servers the one-line explanation and the manager's name for complaints.
Record the audit
Keep screenshots and dates, so you can show what guests saw if a complaint arrives.
Common display gaps
- The fee appears on the dinner menu but not on the brunch, bar or dessert menus.
- The QR menu shows the fee only in a footer that guests never scroll to.
- Online ordering shows the fee only in the cart or the final checkout screen.
- A social post or ad shows a price for a special with no mention of the fee.
- Catering quotes list the service charge in the terms rather than with the menu prices.
- The check calls the fee something different from the menu, such as Misc or Admin.
- Staff describe the fee as a tip for the server when part of it funds other costs.
Each gap is small, and each one breaks the condition the exemption depends on. Fix them at the source file, so the next menu print or website update carries the fee line automatically.
Example: a Los Angeles cafe tidies its fees
Example: a fictional Los Angeles cafe has a 5 percent kitchen fee printed at the bottom of its paper menu, nowhere on its online ordering pages, and on the check as Misc. The owner runs the audit, moves the fee line to the top of every menu and every online menu section, renames the check line Kitchen fee 5%, and adds the line to its catering quote template. For delivery apps, where the fee cannot be shown cleanly, the owner removes it and raises app prices instead. The cafe now shows one consistent message wherever a guest sees a price.
Frequently asked questions
Can California restaurants still charge a service fee?
Yes. Mandatory restaurant and bar fees are exempt from SB 478's all-in price requirement as long as the fee is clearly and conspicuously displayed wherever prices are shown.
Does a card surcharge have to be in the menu price in California?
The Attorney General's guidance says a card fee is generally not mandatory if guests can avoid it by paying another way, but it becomes mandatory if you accept only cards. Card network rules and surcharge laws also apply.
When did the California hidden fees law start?
It took effect on July 1, 2024, and was later amended by SB 1524, which added the restaurant and bar exemption for clearly displayed fees.
References
California Department of Justice, Office of the Attorney General (2024). SB 478 - Hidden Fees (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Restaurant Association (2026). National Restaurant Association comments to the FTC on the Food Delivery Fees ANPRM (Project No. P267101) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Internal Revenue Service (2015). Tips Versus Service Charges: How to Report (FS-2015-8) (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Consumer Price Index: series CUUR0000SEFV01 (opens in a new tab) ↑