Key takeaways
- The IRS says automatic gratuities for large parties are service charges, not tips[1].
- Service charges paid to staff are non-tip wages[1], and a compulsory service charge cannot be counted as a tip under federal wage rules[2].
- Employers may never keep employees' tips[3]; a service charge is the restaurant's money unless distributed, so decide and disclose who receives it.
- Disclose the charge before ordering; in California, restaurant fees must be shown wherever prices appear[4].
Why the label matters
Calling an 18 percent charge on a party of eight a gratuity does not make it a tip. The IRS reminds employers that automatic gratuities are service charges, not tips, and that what an employer or employee calls a payment is not what decides its treatment[1]. The difference changes payroll, tip credits, tax reporting and what you can tell guests about where the money goes.
The IRS uses four factors. If any is missing, there is doubt that the payment is a tip and it may be a service charge[1]:
- The payment must be made free from compulsion.
- The customer must have the unrestricted right to determine the amount.
- The payment should not be the subject of negotiations or dictated by employer policy.
- Generally, the customer has the right to determine who receives the payment.
An automatic charge for parties above a set size fails at least the first three. The IRS lists the large dining party automatic gratuity first among its examples of service charges, alongside banquet event fees and bottle service charges[1].
Tips and automatic gratuities side by side
| Question | Voluntary tip | Automatic gratuity |
|---|---|---|
| Who sets the amount | The guest | The restaurant's policy |
| Can the guest leave nothing | Yes | No, unless the restaurant removes it |
| Tax treatment for staff | Tip income the employee reports to the employer | Non-tip wages when paid to staff |
| Counts toward a tip credit | Yes, where a tip credit is used | No; a compulsory charge is not a tip |
| Who owns the money first | The employee | The restaurant, until it distributes it |
| Can managers share in it | Not from tips; employers may not keep employees' tips | Depends on your policy and state law |
Payroll consequences
Service charges distributed to employees are generally reported as non-tip wages[1], so they go through payroll with normal withholding, rather than being reported by the employee as tips. If the restaurant keeps part of the charge, only the amounts paid out to employees are wages[1].
Federal wage rules add a second point. A compulsory charge for service, such as 15 percent of the bill, is not a tip and cannot be counted as a tip received, even if the employer distributes it to employees[2]. That matters for restaurants that use a tip credit. Under the FLSA an employer may pay tipped employees a cash wage of $2.13 an hour and take a tip credit of up to $5.12 toward the $7.25 federal minimum wage[5]. Service charge money cannot fill that tip credit gap as if it were tips. The same rule says that sums distributed from service charges may be used in their entirety to satisfy the Act's monetary requirements[2], so distributed service charges count as wages paid. Work through the arithmetic with your payroll provider, because many states set a higher minimum wage or do not allow a tip credit at all.
The no tax on tips deduction
Staff will ask about it. For 2025 through 2028, employees in occupations that customarily receive tips may deduct qualified tips, up to $25,000 a year[6]. Because the IRS treats automatic gratuities as service charges rather than tips[1], staff should not assume those amounts count as tips for the deduction. Tell them where the line sits in your payroll, show service charge payouts separately from tips on pay statements, and point them to a tax adviser for their own situation.
Decide who receives it, and say so
An automatic gratuity is the restaurant's money until it is paid out, so you must decide where it goes: all to the service team, shared with the kitchen, or partly kept to cover costs. Each choice is possible under federal rules, but some states and cities regulate how service charges are described and whether they must go to staff, so check yours.
Whatever you choose, describe it honestly. Guests read the word gratuity as money for the server. Employers may never keep employees' tips, including by letting managers or supervisors keep a portion[3], and a guest who learns that a gratuity was partly kept by the house may feel misled. If any of the charge is retained, call it a service charge and say what it covers.
Setting the threshold
- Pick one party size, such as 6 or 8, and apply it to every party at or above it.
- Apply it to events and set menus where service work is planned in advance.
- Do not apply it to small parties on busy nights to raise the average check; that is a pricing decision and should be shown as a price.
- State whether it is calculated before or after tax and discounts.
- Train servers to tell large parties at the start of the meal, not when the check arrives.
Disclosure wording
Example wording for the menu and booking page: “Parties of 8 or more: an 18% service charge is added to your bill. It is paid to the team that serves you. Additional tips are optional.”
- Example for the booking confirmation: repeat the line for every large party booking, so the organizer can tell the group.
- Example for the check: show it as a separate, labeled line, Service charge 18% (party of 8 or more), not merged into the subtotal.
- Example for the tip line: if you leave a tip line on the check, label it Additional tip (optional) so guests do not tip twice by mistake.
- Example server script: “Just so you know, for groups your size there’s an 18 percent service charge on the bill, which goes to the team tonight.”
In California, mandatory restaurant fees are exempt from the hidden fees law only if they are clearly and conspicuously displayed wherever prices are shown[4], so the line belongs on the menu itself, not only on the check. Elsewhere, the same clarity protects you from complaints and disputes.
Should guests be able to remove it?
Some restaurants let a large party ask for the charge to be removed and tip instead. Be careful: if guests can freely change or remove the amount, the payment starts to meet the IRS tip factors again, and the payroll treatment may change. Pick one model and run it consistently. Either it is a fixed service charge, removed only by a manager for a service failure, or it is a suggested gratuity printed on the check that the guest is free to change, which is treated as a tip.
Common mistakes
- Calling it a gratuity and treating it as tips in payroll.
- Counting service charge payouts toward a tip credit.
- Keeping part of a charge labeled gratuity without telling guests.
- Adding it without telling the party until the check arrives.
- Leaving a plain tip line under it, so guests tip twice without realizing.
- Applying it to some large parties and not others, depending on the server or the night.
Each of these turns a reasonable policy into a payroll problem, a complaint or a dispute. One written policy, followed every time, avoids them all.
What it means for your servers
Servers care about the change because it affects their pay. Waitstaff at full-service restaurants earn a median of $27.00 an hour including tips, with an upper quartile of $41.50 and a lower quartile of $19.00, according to National Restaurant Association research[7]. Explain the policy before it starts, show how service charge payouts appear on pay statements, and pay them on a predictable schedule.
Source: National Restaurant Association, 2022[7]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Lower quartile | $19 |
| Median | $27 |
| Upper quartile | $41.5 |
Checklist
Choose the model
Fixed service charge or suggested gratuity. Do not mix them.
Set threshold and rate
Write down the party size, the rate and whether it applies before or after tax and discounts.
Decide distribution
Who receives it and in what shares, checked against state and local rules.
Update payroll
Run distributed service charges through payroll as wages and keep them out of tip credit calculations.
Disclose everywhere
Menu, booking page, confirmation, check and server script, with the same wording.
Brief the team
Explain the change to servers and managers before the first service it applies to.
Frequently asked questions
Is an automatic gratuity a tip?
No. The IRS treats automatic gratuities for large parties as service charges, because the guest does not freely decide the amount. Paid to staff, they are non-tip wages.
Can the restaurant keep part of an automatic gratuity?
Under federal rules a service charge belongs to the employer until it is distributed, but some states and cities restrict how service charges are described or require them to go to staff. If any is kept, call it a service charge and say what it covers.
Does an automatic gratuity count toward the tip credit?
No. Federal wage rules say a compulsory service charge is not a tip and cannot be counted as tips received, although amounts distributed to employees count as wages paid.
References
Internal Revenue Service (2015). Tips Versus Service Charges: How to Report (FS-2015-8) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute (Cornell Law School), eCFR text (2026). 29 CFR § 531.55 - Examples of amounts not received as tips (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute (Cornell Law School), US Code (2026). 29 U.S. Code § 203 - Definitions (Fair Labor Standards Act) (opens in a new tab) ↑
California Department of Justice, Office of the Attorney General (2024). SB 478 - Hidden Fees (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division (2026). Minimum Wages for Tipped Employees (state and federal table) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Internal Revenue Service (2025). One, Big, Beautiful Bill Act: Tax deductions for working Americans and seniors (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Restaurant Association (2022). National Statistics: Restaurant Industry Facts at a Glance (opens in a new tab) ↑