Key takeaways
- Nearly 3 in 4 US restaurant orders are now taken to go[1], which makes a takeout-only Thanksgiving a real option.
- Off-premises traffic at full-service restaurants rose from 19% in 2019 to 30% in 2024[2].
- Decide using last year's data, staff availability, kitchen capacity and what neighbors are doing, not habit.
- If you sell holiday meals to go, run pre-orders with a deadline, timed pickup windows and clear reheating and storage instructions.
Three ways to handle Thanksgiving
Thanksgiving is unusual among restaurant holidays. Most families cook at home, many restaurants close, and yet demand does not disappear: it moves. Some guests want a table so nobody has to cook; others want the turkey and sides cooked for them and picked up; others still go out the night before. Every year owners face the same choice: open for dine-in, close for the day, or sell takeout only.
There is no single right answer. The decision depends on your concept, your neighborhood, your team and your numbers from previous years. What has changed is how much off-premises demand exists. Nearly 75% of all US restaurant traffic now happens off-premises, with almost 3 in 4 orders taken to go[1]. A takeout Thanksgiving that would have looked odd a decade ago is now a familiar choice.
The three models side by side
| Factor | Open for dine-in | Closed | Takeout only |
|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue potential | High if you fill seatings; set menus help | None on the day; possible boost on Wednesday | Moderate to high, mostly pre-sold |
| Staffing | Full team on a family holiday | Team gets the day off | Kitchen and pickup crew only, often finishing early |
| Kitchen load | Holiday menu at full service pace | None | Heavy prep on Tuesday and Wednesday, light on the day |
| Risk | Empty tables if demand is weak; late cancellations | Lost sales to competitors who open | Order errors, pickup bottlenecks, food safety in transit |
| Guest experience | Celebration without cooking | None | Home celebration, less work |
| Best fit | Destination restaurants, hotels, tourist areas, traditional American menus | Small teams, concepts with little holiday fit | Kitchens strong on roasts and sides, loyal local base |
How much takeout demand is there?
Off-premises dining has grown fastest where it used to be smallest. At full-service restaurants, off-premises traffic rose from 19% of all traffic in 2019 to 30% in 2024; at limited-service restaurants it rose from 76% to 83%[2]. Takeout has become routine for many guests: 51% of consumers say ordering takeout or delivery is essential to their lifestyle[3], and two-thirds of Gen Z and millennial adults say takeout is essential to theirs[4].
- 2019
- 2024
Source: National Restaurant Association, 2025[2]
Show the data
| Item | 2019 | 2024 |
|---|---|---|
| Full-service | 19% | 30% |
| Limited-service | 76% | 83% |
For Thanksgiving, that habit shows up as demand for whole meals, sides and desserts that complement home cooking. Pies and sides are often the easiest entry point: they sell to guests who want to cook the turkey themselves, and they fit into normal production without a separate kitchen plan.
Decision criteria
- Your history: what did last Thanksgiving week look like by day and by channel? If you were open, how full were you, and what did it cost to staff?
- Your team: who wants to work, and who needs the day off? Restaurant staff routinely work evenings, weekends and holidays[5], and managers often do the same[6]; a holiday everyone dreads costs you in retention.
- Your kitchen: can it produce dozens or hundreds of holiday meals in two days without starving the regular service?
- Your menu: does a holiday meal fit your concept? A steakhouse or American bistro has an easier case than a ramen bar.
- Your neighborhood: tourist area, hotels, residential streets or offices? Who is around on Thursday?
- Your competition: if most nearby restaurants close, the few that open can fill. If several sell to-go meals, price and quality decide.
A useful test: if you cannot name the person who will run the day and the five people who want to work it, a full dine-in service is the wrong choice.
Running a takeout-only Thanksgiving
Design a short menu
A complete meal for 4 to 6, a smaller meal for 2, a few sides and two pies. Keep each item to something you can produce at volume and that reheats well.
Open pre-orders early
Four to five weeks out, with a deadline a few days before. Take payment at order, so pickups move quickly and no-shows cost you nothing.
Set pickup windows
Offer pickup on Wednesday afternoon and Thursday morning in 15-minute slots, with a cap per slot that your counter can handle.
Plan production by day
Work back from pickup: proteins, sides and pies on a written schedule, with labels printed in advance.
Run pickup like a line
A separate pickup point, orders bagged and labeled by name and slot, one person checking names and one handing over bags.
Follow up
Send a short thank-you with a request for feedback and a note about your Christmas or New Year's offers.
Food safety for holiday meals to go
Holiday takeout moves large amounts of cooked food out of your control, so the instructions matter as much as the cooking. FDA notes that leaving perishable foods out for 2 hours or more allows bacteria to multiply rapidly[7]. Sell meals chilled for reheating rather than hot for eating hours later, unless pickup is timed close to the meal.
- Cool cooked proteins and sides quickly and hold them cold until pickup, following your local code and HACCP plan.
- Label every container with the item, allergens, reheating instructions and a use-by guide.
- Tell guests to refrigerate the meal as soon as they get home if they are not eating within the hour.
- Include written reheating steps, with oven temperatures and times, and say how to check that food is heated through.
- Keep a record of production times and holding temperatures for each batch.
Price the meal from the recipe up
Holiday meal packages are often underpriced because they are costed like a normal menu item. Cost each package from the recipe up: proteins at current invoice prices, every side and sauce, packaging, labels, bags and the extra prep labor on the two days before. Add a margin for waste, because some orders are always changed at the last minute. Compare the total with what guests would spend on groceries plus time, not with your regular menu prices. Then decide which items are add-ons, such as an extra pie or a second side, which raise the average order without complicating production.
If you stay open for dine-in
Restaurants that open on Thanksgiving usually do best with a set holiday menu and fixed seatings, often starting earlier than a normal dinner. Take card guarantees for larger parties, because a no-show at a family table of eight leaves a big gap. Offer a children's plate and a vegetarian main. Staff with volunteers first and pay a premium if you can; it makes the day feel like a choice rather than a punishment. Publish your holiday hours early, and keep the phone answered in the week before, when most bookings and questions arrive.
If you close
Closing is a legitimate choice, and many teams value it. Make it work for the business by planning the days around it. The Wednesday before Thanksgiving is often a strong bar night, as people return home and meet friends. The Friday and Saturday after can be busy with families who are tired of leftovers. Announce the closure early on your website, Google profile, booking page and phone message, and promote the days you are open.
Communicate the plan once, everywhere
Whichever model you choose, guests need to find it quickly. Publish the plan at the same time on your website, Google profile, booking page, ordering site and social accounts, and update the phone greeting or voicemail. Include the dates you are closed, the dates you are open, how to pre-order and the pickup window. The full checklist is in updating holiday hours on every channel. Brief staff too: they will be asked about Thanksgiving by regulars for weeks.
Example: from closed to pre-order
Example (fictional): a neighborhood American bistro had closed on Thanksgiving for years. Its POS showed that sides and pies ordered as add-ons the week before were rising. The owner kept the dining room closed, launched a pre-order menu five weeks out with a dinner for four, three sides and two pies, and took payment at order. Pickups ran Wednesday from 2 to 7 pm in 15-minute slots. The kitchen team worked Tuesday and Wednesday and had Thursday off. The owner's notes for next year: cap the most popular pie earlier, and add a second pickup line between 4 and 6 pm.
Thanksgiving is one of several holiday decisions: see holiday season staffing and scheduling, New Year's Eve planning, Valentine's Day planning and how to prepare for Mother's Day.
Frequently asked questions
Is it worth opening a restaurant on Thanksgiving Day?
It can be for destination restaurants, hotels, tourist areas and traditional American menus with strong demand. For many independents, a takeout-only or closed Thanksgiving with strong Wednesday and weekend service works better.
How far ahead should Thanksgiving pre-orders open?
Four to five weeks ahead, with a firm deadline a few days before so the kitchen can plan production and purchasing.
Should Thanksgiving to-go meals be sold hot or cold?
Chilled for reheating is usually safer and easier, unless pickup is timed close to the meal. FDA warns that perishable food left out for 2 hours or more lets bacteria multiply rapidly[7].
How do we staff a Thanksgiving opening fairly?
Ask for volunteers first, rotate the holiday year to year, and pay a premium if you can. Restaurant staff often work holidays[5], so a fair rotation matters for retention.
References
National Restaurant Association (2025). From Trend to Transformation: Off-Premises Dining Now Essential for Restaurant Consumers, Operators (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Restaurant Association (2025). Report: Takeout, drive-thru, delivery are more popular than ever (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Restaurant Association (2025). The 2025 State of the Industry shows cautious optimism (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Restaurant Association (2025). From Trend to Transformation: Off-Premises Dining Now Essential for Restaurant Consumers, Operators (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Waiters and Waitresses (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Food Service Managers (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Food and Drug Administration (2024). Refrigerator Thermometers: Cold Facts about Food Safety (opens in a new tab) ↑