Key takeaways
- The teen labor pool is shrinking: the first half of 2026 had roughly 250,000 fewer 16-19-year-olds in the labor force than a year earlier[1].
- Set time-off rules by early October: request window, blackout dates and a fair rotation for the biggest days.
- Schedule week by week from last year's covers, adding private-event and takeout load, not from a standard template.
- Holiday tip pools must follow federal law: managers and supervisors may not keep any portion of employees' tips[2].
The season in one view
From mid-November to New Year's Day, restaurant demand changes almost every week. Thanksgiving week brings pre-orders and a busy Wednesday bar night. December fills with office parties and private dining, gift card sales and shoppers at lunch. Christmas Eve and Christmas Day split restaurants into those that close and those that run their best services of the month. New Year's Eve is a single, intense night. All of this lands in the weeks when staff most want time off, students come home and seasonal retail competes for the same workers.
Restaurant work already includes early mornings, late evenings, weekends and holidays, and part-time schedules are common[3]. Managers often work evenings, weekends and holidays, and some work more than 40 hours a week[4]. A holiday schedule built in a hurry stacks those pressures on the same people, which is how restaurants lose good staff in January.
What the labor market looks like
Hiring for the holidays is harder than it was. Teenagers make up 20% of the restaurant workforce, and restaurants employ more than 1.8 million 16-19-year-olds[5]. But in the first half of 2026 there were roughly 250,000 fewer 16-19-year-olds in the US labor force than a year earlier[1]. Turnover remains high: the quits rate in accommodation and food services was 5.0% in September 2026[6], and 77% of operators say recruiting and retaining employees is still a leading challenge[7].
- Teenagers aged 16-19 20%
Source: National Restaurant Association, 2026[5]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Teenagers aged 16-19 | 20% |
The practical lesson: keep the team you have through the season. A schedule that respects people's holidays and spreads the hardest shifts fairly is a retention tool, and it is cheaper than replacing a server in January.
Set time-off rules early
Publish the rules by early October
Say which dates are blackout dates (for example, the Wednesday before Thanksgiving, December Saturdays and New Year's Eve) and which can be requested.
Open a request window
Collect holiday requests in a two-week window, in writing, so nobody wins by asking first in the hallway.
Rotate the biggest days
Whoever worked Christmas Eve or New Year's Eve last year gets first choice of a day off this year. Keep a simple record.
Use a lottery for ties
When too many people ask for the same day, draw names in front of the team rather than deciding privately.
Confirm the schedule four weeks out
Post the full holiday schedule at least four weeks ahead, so staff can plan travel and family time.
Make swaps easy but visible: staff can trade shifts with a manager's approval, recorded in the scheduling app, so coverage never depends on a text thread.
Schedule week by week
| Week | Demand drivers | Staffing moves |
|---|---|---|
| Thanksgiving week | Pre-order production, Wednesday bar night, quiet Thursday or closed | Extra prep on Tuesday and Wednesday; bar staff on Wednesday; day off for most on Thursday if closed |
| First December weeks | Office parties, private dining, holiday shopping lunches | Event captain and servers for private rooms; stronger lunch coverage near shopping areas |
| Mid-December | Peak party weeks, gift card sales | Full schedule; cashier or host trained on gift cards; extra dishwasher on party nights |
| Christmas week | Christmas Eve demand or closure; travel reduces local regulars | Volunteers and rotation for Christmas Eve and Day; lighter weekday lunches |
| New Year's week | New Year's Eve peak, slow early January | Premium shifts for New Year's Eve; plan reduced hours from January 2 |
Use last year's covers by day and by hour as the base, then add what is already on the books: private events, large parties and takeout pre-orders. Each private party needs its own staffing line, because it takes servers out of the main room.
Private parties need their own plan
December private events are where holiday schedules most often break. A party of 40 booked in October looks simple on the calendar, but on the night it needs servers, a bartender, a captain and kitchen time that would otherwise serve the main room. Treat each event as its own shift.
- Assign a captain to every private event, with the host's contact details and the agreed menu and timings.
- Staff from the event's guest count and service style, such as one server per set number of seated guests at your usual standard, plus a bartender for open bars.
- Block the event's kitchen time on the prep schedule and order separately for it.
- Agree in writing how any service charge or gratuity is handled and shared, before the event.
- Confirm final numbers a few days ahead and adjust staffing then, not on the day.
Seasonal hires and returning students
Some 4 in 10 restaurant employees are teens or young adults, and operators say they recruit best among people seeking part-time work and flexible schedules[8]. College students home for winter break and former staff who left for school are often the best seasonal hires: they know the job and sometimes the menu. Contact them in October, before retail recruits them.
- Keep a list of former staff in good standing and ask whether they want holiday shifts.
- Offer short, defined commitments, such as four weeks with guaranteed hours, which suit students.
- Train seasonal hires on one role and one station, not everything.
- Check federal and state rules for minors, including hours on school nights and limits on certain equipment, before scheduling anyone under 18.
- Pair each seasonal hire with an experienced buddy for their first two shifts.
Tips, tip pools and holiday pay
Busy holidays bring more tips and more questions about them. Federal law bars employers from keeping employees' tips for any purpose, including letting managers or supervisors keep any portion, whether or not the employer takes a tip credit[2]. Under the FLSA, employers may pay tipped employees a minimum cash wage of 2.13 dollars an hour and take a tip credit of up to 5.12 dollars against the 7.25 dollar federal minimum wage[9], but many states set higher minimums or ban the tip credit entirely. If you change tip pooling for private events or add a holiday service charge, check how your state treats it and explain it to the team in writing before the season starts.
Holiday premiums are a choice, not usually a legal requirement, but they matter. Paying extra for Christmas Eve, Christmas Day or New Year's Eve, or offering an extra paid day off in January, turns the hardest shifts into ones people are willing to take.
Protect the team from burnout
- Cap consecutive days and doubles per person, and track them in the scheduling tool.
- Give every manager at least one full weekend day off in December.
- Feed the team on long party nights, and arrange rides home after late shifts.
- Run short pre-shifts so everyone knows the parties, the specials and who is in charge.
- Thank people specifically, and close the season with a staff meal or small bonus in January.
Plan January now
The holiday schedule should end with a plan for the slow weeks that follow. Decide in November whether you will reduce hours, close for a staff vacation week or shift to a shorter menu in early January, and tell the team before the season starts. Staff who know they will keep their hours, or know exactly when a paid break will come, are far more likely to stay through the hardest weeks.
Example: a fairer December
Example (fictional): a 110-seat restaurant lost three servers the previous January, all of whom had worked both Christmas Eve and New Year's Eve. This year the GM published time-off rules on October 1, opened a two-week request window, set a rotation so nobody worked both big nights two years in a row and offered time-and-a-half for New Year's Eve. Two former servers home from college picked up four-week contracts with guaranteed weekend shifts. Private parties each got their own captain. The schedule was posted on November 20. In January, nobody quit, and the GM's notes said the request window prevented most of the usual arguments.
For the individual holidays, see Thanksgiving: open, closed or takeout only and New Year's Eve planning. Make sure guests see the hours you are staffing for by following updating holiday hours on every channel, and plan the warm-weather equivalent with opening and running a patio for the season.
Frequently asked questions
How early should restaurants plan holiday schedules?
Publish time-off rules by early October, collect requests in a fixed window and post the full holiday schedule at least four weeks ahead.
Can managers share in the holiday tip pool?
Under federal law, employers may not let managers or supervisors keep any portion of employees' tips[2]. Check your state's rules too, especially for service charges and private events.
Where can restaurants find seasonal staff?
Former staff, college students home for break and people seeking part-time, flexible work, which operators say is where they recruit best[8].
How do we handle too many requests for the same day off?
Use a rotation based on who worked the day last year, then a visible lottery for any remaining ties.
References
National Restaurant Association (2026). Restaurants remain resilient despite challenging business conditions (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute (Cornell Law School), US Code (2026). 29 U.S. Code § 203 - Definitions (Fair Labor Standards Act) (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Waiters and Waitresses (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Food Service Managers (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Restaurant Association (2026). Restaurants remain resilient despite challenging business conditions (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey: series JTS720000000000000QUR (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Restaurant Association (2025). The 2025 State of the Industry shows cautious optimism (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Restaurant Association (2025). The 2025 State of the Industry shows cautious optimism (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division (2026). Minimum Wages for Tipped Employees (state and federal table) (opens in a new tab) ↑