Food Safety, Health and Licensing

How to Build an Allergen Matrix for Your Menu

Build an allergen matrix from your recipes and supplier specs, keep it current when products change, and turn it into a guest-facing allergen menu.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. What an allergen matrix is, and why paper beats memory
  2. Choose the format before you start
  3. Build it in seven steps
  4. Example: one row, worked through
  5. Questions to put to every supplier
  6. Keep it current with triggers
  7. Turn the matrix into a guest-facing allergen menu
  8. Common mistakes
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References
Food Safety, Health and Licensing: How to Build an Allergen Matrix for Your MenuArticle coverFOOD SAFETY, HEALTH AND LICENSINGHow to Build anAllergen Matrix forYour MenuAva for RestaurantsInsightsFood Safety, Health and Licensing: How to Build an Allergen Matrix for Your MenuArticle coverFOOD SAFETY, HEALTH AND LICENSINGHow to Build anAllergen Matrix forYour MenuAva for Restaurants

Key takeaways

  • An allergen matrix lists every dish against the nine major allergens and is built from sub-recipes and supplier spec sheets, not memory.
  • In a CDC study, a quarter of restaurant managers said they had no ingredient lists for any menu items[1].
  • The 2022 Food Code asks restaurants to tell guests in writing about major allergens in unpackaged food, and a matrix is the easiest way to do it[2].
  • Tie updates to triggers: a new supplier, a substitute product, a recipe change or a new menu item.

What an allergen matrix is, and why paper beats memory

An allergen matrix is a grid. Each row is a dish or component, each column is one of the nine major food allergens, and each cell says whether that allergen is present, may be present through shared equipment, or is absent. It sounds like admin. In practice it is the document your servers, hosts, phone staff and cooks use to answer the question every allergic guest asks: what is in this?

Most restaurants do not have one. In CDC interviews with 277 restaurant managers, 55.2% said they had ingredient lists for all or most menu items, 18.4% for some, and 25.3% for none[1]. Without a list, the answer to an allergy question depends on who is working and what they remember about a sauce someone else made.

Restaurants with ingredient lists for menu itemsManager responses, CDC EHS-Net, 277 restaurants, 2014
Restaurants with ingredient lists for menu itemsDonut chart. All or most items: 55.2%; Some items: 18.4%; No items: 25.3%; Unsure: 1.1%.All or most items: 55.2%Some items: 18.4%No items: 25.3%Unsure: 1.1%277 managers
  • All or most items 55.2%
  • Some items 18.4%
  • No items 25.3%
  • Unsure 1.1%

Source: CDC Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 2017[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
All or most items55.2%
Some items18.4%
No items25.3%
Unsure1.1%

The matrix also helps you meet a newer expectation. The 2022 FDA Food Code added a requirement for the permit holder to notify consumers in writing when major food allergens are ingredients in unpackaged food, and the supporting annex lists brochures, menu notes, table tents and placards as acceptable forms[2]. Whether your inspector enforces it depends on the edition your state has adopted, but a good matrix lets you meet it with little extra work.

Choose the format before you start

Common allergen matrix formats and their trade-offs
FormatWorks well forWatch out for
Spreadsheet with one tab per menuIndependent restaurants with up to a few dozen dishesVersion control: lock edits to one manager and date every change
Recipe-costing or inventory softwareGroups that already cost recipes in softwareCheck the allergen fields roll up from sub-recipes, not just top-level items
POS item tagsShowing allergens to staff at the moment of orderingTags drift from the real recipe unless someone owns them
Printed binderBackup at the pass and host standMust be reprinted every time the master changes, with the date on each page

Whatever you choose, keep one master and treat every other copy, such as the printed binder or the guest sheet, as an output of that master. Two masters always disagree eventually.

Build it in seven steps

  1. List components, not just dishes

    Start with sub-recipes: dressings, sauces, marinades, spice rubs, doughs, batters, stocks and garnishes. Most hidden allergens live here. Each dish row then points to its components.

  2. Gather supplier spec sheets

    For every purchased product, file the current ingredient statement with the date received. Include oils, sprays, breadcrumbs, bases and anything used to finish a plate.

  3. Use nine columns

    Milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, soybeans and sesame. Add columns for other allergens only if you can keep them accurate.

  4. Use three values only

    Contains, may contain through shared equipment, or not present. Avoid free text in the cells; it becomes unreadable at the pass.

  5. Mark shared equipment honestly

    If fries share oil with breaded shrimp, the fries row shows may contain for wheat and crustacean shellfish, whatever the potato itself contains.

  6. Have a second person check

    The chef builds the matrix; a manager checks each row against the spec sheets. Both initial and date the master.

  7. Publish the outputs

    Print the staff binder, update POS tags and create the guest-facing sheet from the same master the same day.

The allergen list itself, including what changed when sesame was added, is covered in the nine major food allergens, including sesame. It matters here because the definition includes any ingredient containing protein derived from those foods[2], so casein, whey, egg wash and fish sauce all belong in the right column.

Example: one row, worked through

Example: a fictional neighborhood grill wants to add a Crispy Chicken Sandwich to its matrix. The dish has six components. Working through them shows why component rows matter.

Example allergen build-up for one sandwich, fictional restaurant
ComponentSourceContainsMay containNote
Brioche bunBakery spec sheet, dated this monthWheat, milk, eggsSesameShared line with seeded buns
Buttermilk-brined chickenHouse sub-recipeMilkNoneBrine uses buttermilk
Seasoned flour coatingSupplier blendWheatSoybeansSpec lists soy flour as possible
Fryer oilSupplier letterNoneCrustacean shellfishShared with popcorn shrimp
Spicy mayoHouse sub-recipeEggs, soybeansNoneSoybean-oil mayo base
PicklesSupplier specNoneNoneChecked, no allergens declared

The dish row in this example reads: contains wheat, milk, eggs and soybeans; may contain sesame and crustacean shellfish. A server who only knew the recipe card would have said milk and wheat. The shared fryer is the detail guests with a shellfish allergy most need to hear.

Questions to put to every supplier

Spec sheets answer most questions, but not all. A short written request to each supplier, sent when you open the account and again each year, closes the gaps that labels leave open.

  1. Please send the current ingredient statement for every item we buy, with the date it was issued.
  2. Which of these products contain any of the nine major food allergens, including sesame?
  3. Which products are made on lines or in facilities shared with any of the nine?
  4. Are your frying and cooking oils highly refined? Please confirm in writing for each oil.
  5. How will you notify us when a product is reformulated, relabeled or replaced by a substitute?
  6. Which items might you substitute when they are out of stock, and with what?

File each answer with the spec sheet it relates to. When a supplier will not answer a question, record the allergen as may contain until it does. That is not overcaution: it is the honest state of your knowledge, and it is what a guest with a severe allergy needs to hear.

Give one person ownership of the whole file. In most independent restaurants that is the chef or kitchen manager, with the general manager as the second checker. Write both names on the master, so that when either of them is away, the team knows who decides whether a new product can be used.

Keep it current with triggers

A matrix that was right in January can be wrong by March without anyone changing a recipe. Distributors substitute brands, bakeries reformulate, and a cook improves a sauce on a slow night. Tie updates to events, not to a calendar.

  • New supplier or new brand of any ingredient: update before first use.
  • Substitute product on a delivery: receiving staff hold it until the manager checks the label.
  • Recipe change, including a garnish or finishing oil: the chef updates the sub-recipe row the same day.
  • New menu item or special: no matrix row, no sale.
  • Equipment change, such as moving shrimp into the main fryer: update every row that shares it.
  • Quarterly: pull five products at random and compare the label in hand with the spec sheet on file.

Daily specials are where matrices fail most. Add a blank special row to the line-up sheet that the chef must complete before service, with all nine allergens marked.

Turn the matrix into a guest-facing allergen menu

The guest version should be simpler than the kitchen version. List dishes and mark the allergens they contain, add a clear note about shared fryers and prep areas, and date the sheet. Put a line on the main menu telling guests to inform their server about allergies before ordering, and make the allergen sheet available at the table, at the host stand and on your website if you publish menus online.

Keep the wording factual. A sheet that says contains or shared equipment, ask your server is honest. A sheet that says allergen-free or safe for allergies makes a promise your kitchen cannot always keep. If your restaurant takes orders by phone, make sure whoever answers, whether a host or an AI phone assistant such as Ava, reads from the same dated sheet and passes detailed questions to a manager rather than answering from a summary.

Allergy questions are not rare edge cases. When federal allergen labeling law passed, the original eight major allergens accounted for 90% of food allergies and serious allergic reactions in the US[3], and sesame has been covered by FDA requirements since January 1, 2023[4]. A guest sheet built from the matrix answers most questions before they reach the kitchen.

Common mistakes

  1. Building the matrix from the menu description instead of the recipe and spec sheets.
  2. Leaving out fryer oil, grill sprays, butter finishes and garnishes.
  3. Marking may contain for everything to be safe, which makes the sheet useless and pushes guests to guess.
  4. Letting POS tags, binder and guest sheet drift apart; they must all come from one dated master.
  5. Never testing it: ask a new server to answer three allergy questions using only the binder, and see where they get stuck.

Once the matrix is in place, train people to use it with allergen training for front and back of house, and protect it in the kitchen with the separation practices in preventing allergen cross-contact in the kitchen. For local posting or notice rules, see state food allergen laws for restaurants.

Frequently asked questions

What is an allergen matrix?

A grid listing every dish or component against the nine major food allergens, showing whether each is present, may be present through shared equipment, or is absent. It is built from recipes and supplier ingredient statements.

Do restaurants have to provide allergen information in writing?

The 2022 FDA Food Code includes a written notification requirement for major allergens in unpackaged food[2]. It applies where your state or local code has adopted that provision, so check with your health department.

How often should an allergen matrix be updated?

Whenever a supplier, brand, recipe, special or piece of shared equipment changes, plus a quarterly spot-check of labels against the spec sheets on file.

Should we mark dishes as allergen-free?

Avoid it. State what the dish contains and where equipment is shared, and invite guests to talk to the server or manager about their allergy.

References

  1. CDC Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (2017). Restaurant Food Allergy Practices: Six Selected Sites, United States, 2014 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. US Food and Drug Administration (2022). FDA Food Code 2022 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. US Food and Drug Administration (2004). Food Allergies (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. US Food and Drug Administration (2023). Food Allergies (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo