Takeout, Delivery and Online Ordering

First-Party vs Third-Party Online Ordering

Compare direct ordering with delivery marketplaces on margin, guest data, reach and workload, with a worked Example order and a hybrid plan.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Side by side
  3. A worked Example: one order, two channels
  4. When marketplaces earn their fee
  5. When direct ordering wins
  6. A hybrid plan that works for most restaurants
  7. What the guest experiences in each channel
  8. Questions to ask before you sign up for either
  9. Decision checklist
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Takeout, Delivery and Online Ordering: First-Party vs Third-Party Online OrderingArticle coverTAKEOUT, DELIVERY AND ONLINE ORDERINGFirst-Party vsThird-Party OnlineOrderingAva for RestaurantsInsightsTakeout, Delivery and Online Ordering: First-Party vs Third-Party Online OrderingArticle coverTAKEOUT, DELIVERY AND ONLINE ORDERINGFirst-Party vsThird-Party OnlineOrderingAva for Restaurants

Key takeaways

  • Marketplaces bring reach: 68% of delivery customers ordered through a third-party service in the past six months.
  • They cost margin: two in three restaurants pay an average 15% to 29.9% of the transaction, and many make no profit on those orders.
  • Direct ordering keeps the guest relationship and data, but you have to drive the traffic yourself.
  • Most restaurants do best with both: marketplaces for discovery, direct ordering for repeat guests.

The short answer

First-party ordering means guests order from you directly, on your website, your app or by phone, and you own the transaction. Third-party ordering means guests order through a marketplace such as a delivery app, which lists your menu among many others, takes the payment and usually arranges the driver. Neither is better in every case. Marketplaces are a customer acquisition channel with a high per-order cost. Direct ordering is a retention channel with a low per-order cost and a marketing job attached.

The numbers show why restaurants end up using both. Third-party delivery is available at 58% of limited-service and 32% of full-service restaurants[1], and 68% of delivery customers ordered through a third-party service in the past six months, rising to 79% of Gen Z adults[2]. Ignoring marketplaces means ignoring where many guests start. But two in three restaurants say the average fee they pay those platforms is between 15% and 29.9% of the transaction[3], and in a May 2026 survey 47% of full-service and 43% of limited-service operators said they make no profit on third-party delivery orders[4].

Delivery customers who ordered through a third-party service in the past six months
Delivery customers who ordered through a third-party service in the past six monthsBar chart. All delivery customers: 68%; Gen Z adults: 79%; Baby boomers: 42%.All delivery customersAll delivery customers: 68%68%Gen Z adultsGen Z adults: 79%79%Baby boomersBaby boomers: 42%42%Delivery customers who ordered through a third-party service in the past six monthsBar chart. All delivery customers: 68%; Gen Z adults: 79%; Baby boomers: 42%.All delivery customersAll delivery customers: 68%68%Gen Z adultsGen Z adults: 79%79%Baby boomersBaby boomers: 42%42%

Source: National Restaurant Association, 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
All delivery customers68%
Gen Z adults79%
Baby boomers42%

Side by side

First-party vs third-party ordering on the factors that matter
FactorFirst-party (your site, app or phone)Third-party marketplace
Cost per orderPayment processing and your ordering software, plus delivery if you offer itCommission on each order, often with marketing and processing fees on top
Guest dataNames, emails, order history and consent are yoursThe platform holds the relationship; you see limited details
ReachOnly guests who already know you or find your siteGuests browsing the app who have never heard of you
Pricing controlYou set prices, fees and promotionsYou set item prices, but the platform sets guest fees and ranking
DeliveryYou arrange it, or use an on-demand courierUsually included, with drivers you do not manage
Problems and refundsYou decide and talk to the guestPlatform decides first; you may be charged for errors
WorkloadYou build traffic, answer calls, run promotionsPlatform does marketing; you manage tablets, menus and disputes

The pattern is consistent: the marketplace does the hard part of finding new guests and charges for it on every order, including orders from guests who would have come to you anyway. Direct ordering is cheaper per order but only fills up if you send guests to it.

A worked Example: one order, two channels

The best way to compare channels is one order at your own costs. The figures below are fictional and labelled Example; replace them with your own contract and food cost.

Example: a $40 delivery order through each channel (fictional figures)
LineMarketplace orderDirect order with on-demand courier
Menu price of food$40.00$40.00
Commission or platform fee (Example 25%)$10.00$0.00
Payment processing (Example 3%)Included in some plans$1.20
Courier or delivery cost to the restaurant (Example)Included$7.00, partly offset by a guest delivery fee of $4.00
Packaging (Example)$1.50$1.50
Food and labor (Example 66% of menu price)$26.40$26.40
What is left (Example)$2.10$7.40

In this Example the marketplace order leaves very little, which is why so many operators report no profit on them[4], and why 83% of limited-service and 66% of full-service operators charge more for items ordered through a third party[5]. The direct order leaves more, but only if the guest found you. If the marketplace brought that guest for the first time and they later order direct, the commission bought you a customer, not just an order.

Pickup changes the math again. Marketplace pickup orders usually carry a lower rate than delivery, and direct pickup orders cost little beyond processing. If many of your guests live nearby, pushing pickup on your own channel is often the single biggest margin lever.

When marketplaces earn their fee

  • New openings and new neighborhoods: a listing reaches people who do not know you yet.
  • Off-peak capacity: an extra order at 3 pm uses a kitchen that would otherwise be idle, so a thin margin can still add profit.
  • Late-night or delivery-heavy guests: if your guests expect app delivery, being absent sends them elsewhere.
  • Testing a concept: a marketplace is a cheap way to test demand for a new item or virtual brand.

Even then, treat each marketplace as a paid ad with a known cost per order. If the cost per order is higher than what a new guest is worth to you, cut back promotions, raise app prices or narrow the radius.

When direct ordering wins

  • Repeat guests: regulars who order weekly cost the full commission every time on a marketplace.
  • Large and catering orders: a 20-person office lunch should come to you directly, with a call to confirm details.
  • Pickup orders: guests who live nearby do not need a driver.
  • Loyalty and promotions: loyalty membership affects where 65% of drive-thru users and over 60% of takeout and delivery users order[6], and you can only run your own program on your own channel.
  • Guest data you can use: with consent, emails and texts let you bring guests back on slow nights without paying for each visit.

52% of consumers take part in a restaurant loyalty or rewards program[7], so a simple points or visit-based reward on your own ordering page gives regulars a reason to skip the app.

A hybrid plan that works for most restaurants

  1. Keep marketplace menus focused

    List items that travel well and earn their margin after commission. Leave off low-margin, fragile dishes.

  2. Price channels on purpose

    Set marketplace prices to cover commission, packaging and refunds, and keep your direct prices at in-store levels. Our guide to pricing on delivery apps shows the formula.

  3. Make direct ordering the easiest path

    Put the order button at the top of your website, on your Google profile and on every receipt and bag.

  4. Give guests a reason to switch

    Offer loyalty rewards, a first-order thank-you or free pickup items on your own channel, within the rules of your marketplace contracts.

  5. Measure cost per order by channel

    Each month, total what each channel cost you and divide by orders. Track how many marketplace guests later order direct.

  6. Review contracts twice a year

    Check commission tiers, marketing fees and error-charge terms, and move to a lower tier if the extra reach is not paying back.

The goal is not to leave marketplaces. It is to make sure each marketplace order is either profitable on its own or brings in a guest you can keep. For the practical steps, see moving delivery app customers to direct ordering.

What the guest experiences in each channel

Margin is only half of the comparison. The guest's experience differs too, and it shapes whether they come back. On a marketplace, the guest sees your listing next to dozens of competitors, pays fees set by the platform and contacts the platform, not you, when something goes wrong. If a driver is late, your rating can suffer for a problem you did not cause. If the guest gets a refund, the platform decides, and you may only learn about it from a line on your statement.

On your own channel, you control the menu photos, the pickup instructions and the tone of the confirmation. When an order is late, you can call the guest, apologize and fix it, which is often the moment a one-off customer becomes a regular. You also choose how to handle problems, with your own refund rules and your own staff.

The trade-off is that you carry the support load. Guests ordering direct will phone the restaurant, often during service, to ask where an order is or to change it. Plan for that before you push volume to your own channel: give phone staff the order screen, a clear credit rule and a script, or route after-hours calls to a service that can take a message and a callback number.

Questions to ask before you sign up for either

For a marketplace: which commission tier am I on, and what does each tier include? Who pays for promotions I opt into? What are the error-charge rules and dispute windows? Can I set different prices on the app? How quickly are payouts made?

For direct ordering: does it integrate with my POS and kitchen screens? What does each order cost me, including processing? Do I get guest emails and opt-in for marketing? Can I run loyalty and promo codes? Who answers support calls on a Friday night?

Write the answers into one sheet and revisit it every six months. Contracts, tiers and guest habits change faster than most restaurants review them.

Decision checklist

  • Do more than half of your off-premises guests live within a short drive? Push direct pickup.
  • Is most of your delivery volume from guests who have ordered before? Shift them to direct with loyalty.
  • Are you new, or entering a new area? Lean on marketplaces for discovery, with tight menus and prices.
  • Do you have a team member who can run email, texts and social for direct ordering? If not, start with the website button and receipts.
  • Can your kitchen handle both channels at peak? If not, throttle marketplace orders first on busy nights.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between first-party and third-party online ordering?

First-party ordering happens on your own website, app or phone line, so you own the transaction and guest data. Third-party ordering happens on a marketplace that lists many restaurants, takes payment and usually arranges delivery, in exchange for a commission.

Is commission-free online ordering really free?

Not entirely. Direct ordering avoids marketplace commissions, but you still pay payment processing, ordering software and any delivery service, and you need to market the channel so guests use it.

Should a restaurant leave delivery apps entirely?

Usually not. Marketplaces reach guests who have never heard of you. Most restaurants keep a focused marketplace menu with prices that cover the commission and move repeat guests to direct ordering.

How do I know if a delivery app order is profitable?

Take the menu price, subtract the commission and any fees, packaging, refunds and your food and labor cost for the items. If little or nothing is left, raise app prices, trim the app menu or reduce paid promotions.

References

  1. National Restaurant Association (2026). National Restaurant Association comments to the FTC on the Food Delivery Fees ANPRM (Project No. P267101) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. National Restaurant Association (2026). National Restaurant Association comments to the FTC on the Food Delivery Fees ANPRM (Project No. P267101) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. National Restaurant Association (2026). National Restaurant Association comments to the FTC on the Food Delivery Fees ANPRM (Project No. P267101) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. National Restaurant Association (2026). National Restaurant Association comments to the FTC on the Food Delivery Fees ANPRM (Project No. P267101) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. National Restaurant Association (2026). National Restaurant Association comments to the FTC on the Food Delivery Fees ANPRM (Project No. P267101) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. National Restaurant Association (2025). From Trend to Transformation: Off-Premises Dining Now Essential for Restaurant Consumers, Operators (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. National Restaurant Association (2024). Where operators plan to invest in tech (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo