Key takeaways
- Rewards move behavior: being in a rewards program influences 61% of delivery customers' dining choices.
- Target repeat, nearby guests first; they cost the most in commission and are the easiest to move.
- Use bag inserts with a trackable code, a clear reason to switch and your own price advantage.
- Only text or email guests who opted in to your own list; TCPA damages start at $500 per violation.
Who is worth moving
Not every delivery app guest needs to become a direct customer. Someone who orders from you once a year while visiting town is a fine marketplace customer. The guests worth moving are the regulars: people who order every week or two, live within your own delivery or pickup range and spend at or above your average ticket. Each of their orders pays a marketplace fee that two in three restaurants put at 15% to 29.9% of the transaction[1], and they already like your food.
Marketplaces are where many of these guests started. 68% of delivery customers ordered through a third-party service in the past six months[2]. The aim is not to stop that. It is to give the guests who keep coming back a better reason to order from you directly.
Start by finding them. Most platforms show repeat-customer counts, even if they do not share contact details. Look at the share of orders from repeat guests and the neighborhoods they order from. If a large share of app orders come from within a short drive, direct pickup is your biggest opportunity.
Read your platform agreement first
Before you print anything, check what your marketplace agreements allow. Common points to look for:
- Whether you can include your own marketing material in bags for app orders.
- Restrictions on using guest names, phone numbers or addresses that the platform passes to you for fulfillment. Treat that information as for delivering the order only, unless the guest separately gives it to you.
- Any rules on advertising lower prices elsewhere, and whether certain rates depend on price parity.
- Rules about referencing the platform's name or logo in your materials.
When in doubt, keep inserts generic: invite the guest to your website and give them a reason to visit, without mentioning the platform or using data you received from it.
Bag inserts that actually work
A bag insert is the only marketing that reaches every app guest at the moment they are happiest with your food. Make it small, specific and trackable.
Lead with one reason to switch
"Order direct for our menu prices" or "Free garlic knots on your first direct order." One clear benefit beats a list.
Add a scannable code and a short web address
The code should open your ordering page directly, not your home page, and work on any phone.
Use a unique promo code
A code used only on inserts lets you count how many guests switched. Change it each quarter.
Set a sensible limit
One use per guest and an end date, so the offer does not become a permanent discount.
Print it to survive the bag
Thick card, no tiny print, and placed on top of the food where it will be seen.
Make packing it automatic
Put a stack at the packing station and add "insert" to the packing checklist for app orders.
Example: a fictional pizzeria prints a card that reads "Love it? Order direct next time for in-store prices and a free side on your first order. Scan to order." with a code unique to the inserts. After eight weeks, it counts 140 first-time direct orders using the code, of which 60 order again within a month. The insert cost a few cents each.
Give guests a lasting reason, not just a coupon
A one-time discount gets one order. A reason to stay gets a regular. Loyalty is the strongest lever: being in a rewards program influences the dining choices of 61% of delivery customers, compared with 54% of quick-service patrons and 41% of table-service diners[3], and membership affects where over 60% of takeout and delivery users order[4].
Keep the program simple enough to explain on the insert: points per dollar, a free item after a set number of orders or a birthday reward. Run it only on your own channel, so the benefit exists only when guests order direct.
Other lasting reasons:
- Price: if your app prices are higher to cover the commission, your direct prices are already lower. Say so. See pricing menu items on delivery apps.
- Exclusive items: a dish, a family bundle or a sauce available only on your own ordering page.
- Better service: accurate pickup times, a direct line to the restaurant when something goes wrong and notes that the kitchen actually reads.
- App-only offers on your own app: nearly 9 in 10 off-premises consumers say they would use limited-time app-only offers[5].
- Off-peak deals: roughly 8 in 10 off-premises customers would take discounts for ordering on less busy days or times[6], which also fills your quiet hours.
Make the direct path the easy path
Many guests order through a marketplace because it is the first thing they find. Fix the places where they look.
- Put an "Order online" button at the top of your website, linking straight to your ordering page.
- Set the order link on your Google Business Profile and other listings to your own ordering page.
- Print the link and code on receipts, menus, table tents and to-go bags for every order, not just app orders.
- Save card details and past orders for returning guests so reordering takes a few taps.
- Answer the phone or call back quickly. Guests who call with a question and get no answer often open an app instead.
Follow up only with consent
Once a guest orders direct, ask whether they want offers by email or text, with a clear unchecked box and a description of what they will receive. Email and text are what turn a one-off switch into a habit, but they come with rules. The Telephone Consumer Protection Act lets consumers sue for actual losses or $500 per violation, whichever is greater, and courts can triple damages for willful violations[7]. Marketing texts need prior express written consent, a clear way to opt out and respect for calling hours: FCC rules bar telephone solicitations before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. at the recipient's location[8].
Never add phone numbers you received from a marketplace order to your marketing list. Those were shared to deliver food, not to market to the guest. Our guide to SMS marketing and TCPA consent covers the details.
Mistakes that send guests back to the apps
Guests who try your direct channel once will judge it against the app they know. A few common problems undo the work of the inserts.
- A slow or clumsy ordering page. If the menu takes long to load on a phone, needs an account before checkout or does not accept wallet payments, guests go back to the app on the second order.
- Delivery that is worse than the app's. If you offer direct delivery, it has to arrive as reliably as a marketplace order. If you cannot match that, push direct pickup instead and be honest about delivery times.
- Offers that end without warning. Guests who switched for a reward and then find it gone feel misled. Give end dates in the offer itself.
- No answer when something goes wrong. A direct guest with a missing item who cannot reach you will not order direct again. Make sure the phone is answered or a callback is promised and kept.
- Different menus. If items guests liked on the app are missing from your own page, they assume you are hiding something. Keep your own menu at least as complete as the app menu.
Ask a few regulars to order through your direct channel and tell you honestly what was harder than the app. Fix those things before you spend more on inserts or offers.
A 90-day plan and how to measure it
| Weeks | Action | What to measure |
|---|---|---|
| 1–2 | Check agreements, set direct prices, add order buttons to website and Google profile | Direct orders per week before changes |
| 3–4 | Launch bag inserts with a unique code; add insert to packing checklist | Code redemptions per week |
| 5–8 | Launch a simple loyalty reward on your own channel; ask for email and text opt-in at checkout | Opt-in rate, repeat direct orders |
| 9–12 | Add an off-peak direct-only offer; review app menu and prices | Share of off-premises orders that are direct |
At the end of the 90 days, compare three numbers with your starting point: direct orders per week, the share of off-premises orders that came direct and your total commission paid. If direct orders rose and commission fell, keep going and test a stronger offer. If the code was barely used, change the reason to switch before changing anything else.
Frequently asked questions
Can I put flyers in delivery app bags?
Usually, but check your platform agreement first. Keep inserts about your own restaurant and ordering page, avoid using the platform's name or logo, and never use guest contact details shared by the platform for marketing.
What is the best incentive to get customers to order direct?
A lasting reason works better than a one-off coupon: lower direct prices, a simple loyalty reward that only exists on your channel, exclusive items and reliable service. Use a first-order offer to start the habit.
Can I text customers who ordered through a delivery app?
Not for marketing using numbers the platform shared to fulfill the order. Invite guests to your own list and text only those who give prior express written consent, with an easy opt-out.
How do I measure whether bag inserts work?
Print a unique promo code on the inserts, count redemptions on your direct channel each week and track how many of those guests order again within 30 days.
References
National Restaurant Association (2026). National Restaurant Association comments to the FTC on the Food Delivery Fees ANPRM (Project No. P267101) (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Restaurant Association (2026). National Restaurant Association comments to the FTC on the Food Delivery Fees ANPRM (Project No. P267101) (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Restaurant Association (2025). Restaurant Industry Poised for Growth in 2025 (2025 State of the Restaurant Industry press release) (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Restaurant Association (2025). From Trend to Transformation: Off-Premises Dining Now Essential for Restaurant Consumers, Operators (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Restaurant Association (2025). From Trend to Transformation: Off-Premises Dining Now Essential for Restaurant Consumers, Operators (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Restaurant Association (2025). Report: Takeout, drive-thru, delivery are more popular than ever (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute (Cornell Law School), US Code (2026). 47 U.S. Code § 227 - Restrictions on use of telephone equipment (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute (Cornell Law School), eCFR text of FCC rule (2026). 47 CFR § 64.1200 - Delivery restrictions (opens in a new tab) ↑