Takeout, Delivery and Online Ordering

Delivery App Promotions: Are They Worth It?

Measure delivery app promos and sponsored listings by new versus repeat guests and margin per order, with a worked example and clear stop rules.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. The real question behind every promo
  2. Know the four kinds of promotion
  3. Do the margin math before you launch
  4. New guests versus guests you already have
  5. Off-peak promotions usually win
  6. Sponsored listings: a separate test
  7. A decision checklist
  8. Turning promo guests into direct guests
  9. Example: judging a campaign after 60 days
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Takeout, Delivery and Online Ordering: Delivery App Promotions: Are They Worth It?Article coverTAKEOUT, DELIVERY AND ONLINE ORDERINGDelivery AppPromotions: Are TheyWorth It?Ava for RestaurantsInsightsTakeout, Delivery and Online Ordering: Delivery App Promotions: Are They Worth It?Article coverTAKEOUT, DELIVERY AND ONLINE ORDERINGDelivery AppPromotions: Are TheyWorth It?Ava for Restaurants

Key takeaways

  • A delivery promotion is worth it only if it brings in guests who would not have ordered anyway and some of them come back at full price.
  • Work out margin per promo order before you launch, including commission, the discount you fund and food and labor.
  • Off-peak offers usually make more sense than peak ones, and most off-premises guests say they would use them[1].
  • Set a test window, a target and a stop rule in advance, and judge results on repeat orders 30 to 60 days later, not on launch-week volume.

The real question behind every promo

Delivery apps make it easy to switch on a promotion: a percentage off, a free item, free delivery or a sponsored spot at the top of the list. Guests respond to deals. Over 80% of consumers use offers such as BOGO deals, combo meals or real-time specials[2], and nearly 9 in 10 off-premises consumers say they would use limited-time app-only offers[3]. So a promotion will almost always raise orders. The question is whether it raises profit.

That question is sharper on delivery apps because the base margin is thin. In a May 2026 survey, 47% of full-service and 43% of limited-service operators said they do not make a profit on third-party delivery orders[4]. Two in three restaurants pay average platform fees between 15% and 29.9% of the transaction[5]. A discount on top of that can turn a break-even order into a loss.

Know the four kinds of promotion

Common delivery app promotion types and what they really cost
TypeHow it worksWho paysBest use
Percent off the orderGuest gets a discount on the subtotal, sometimes with a capUsually you, sometimes shared with the platformNew guest trial in slow periods
Free or discounted itemBuy one get one, or a free side with an entreeYou, at food and packaging costPushing a high-margin item or a new dish
Free or reduced deliveryDelivery fee waived above a minimumYou, the platform or bothRaising order size above a set amount
Sponsored listing or adHigher placement in search or category pagesYou, per click, per order or per dayVisibility in a crowded area

Read the terms for each campaign. Some platforms share the cost of a promotion, some charge the full commission on the pre-discount price, and some charge for ads separately. The structure changes the math more than the headline discount.

Do the margin math before you launch

Work out what one promo order earns you. Use your own numbers. As a starting point, food and labor each take roughly 33 cents of every dollar of restaurant sales[6].

Example: a fictional pizza restaurant considers a 20%-off promotion on orders over $30 on a delivery app. Its typical promo order is $32 before the discount. In this Example the platform commission is 25%, inside the range most restaurants report[5], and is charged on the discounted subtotal.

Example margin on one $32 promo order (fictional numbers for illustration)
LineWithout promoWith 20% off
Order subtotal$32.00$25.60
Platform commission at 25%minus $8.00minus $6.40
Food at 33% of full priceminus $10.56minus $10.56
Packagingminus $1.20minus $1.20
Kitchen labor for the orderminus $4.00minus $4.00
Contribution before rent and overhead$8.24$3.44

In this Example, each promo order still contributes something, but less than half as much as a full-price order. The promo is only worth running if it brings in orders the restaurant would not otherwise get, and if enough new guests come back without a discount. If the commission were charged on the pre-discount price, the contribution would drop further.

New guests versus guests you already have

A promotion that mostly discounts your regulars is a price cut, not marketing. The key measurement is how many promo orders come from guests who had never ordered from you before.

  1. Get the new-guest share

    Most merchant portals show new versus returning customers for a campaign. If yours does not, ask your platform account contact.

  2. Count repeat orders

    Track how many new promo guests order again within 30 and 60 days, and whether that repeat order was at full price.

  3. Compare with a quiet period

    Look at orders in the same weeks without a promotion to estimate how many you would have got anyway.

  4. Check order size

    Promotions with a minimum often raise basket size. Compare average order value with and without the offer.

  5. Write down the result

    Keep a one-line record of each campaign: dates, offer, orders, new-guest share, repeat rate, contribution.

If the new-guest share is low and repeat orders at full price are rare, stop the campaign even if sales looked good during it.

Off-peak promotions usually win

Discounts make most sense when the kitchen has spare capacity. Labor is already scheduled, the line is not stretched, and an extra order costs mostly food and packaging. Guests are willing: roughly 8 in 10 off-premises customers say they would take advantage of discounts for ordering on less busy days or at less busy times[1].

Off-premises customers who would use discounts for ordering on less busy days or at less busy times
Off-premises customers who would use discounts for ordering on less busy days or at less busy timesDonut chart. Would use off-peak discounts: 80%.Would use off-peak discounts: 80%80%
  • Would use off-peak discounts 80%

Source: National Restaurant Association, 2025[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Would use off-peak discounts80%
  • Run promos on your slowest days or dayparts, such as Monday and Tuesday dinner or mid-afternoon.
  • Avoid promotions on Friday and Saturday nights unless you have real spare capacity. Extra orders at peak raise ticket times and hurt ratings.
  • Use free items on high-margin dishes, such as a free dessert or drink, rather than percentage discounts on the whole order.
  • Set a minimum order that is above your typical basket so the promotion nudges guests to add an item.

Paying for placement is different from discounting. A sponsored listing can bring you in front of guests who would never have scrolled to your name, which matters most in dense areas with many similar restaurants. It also brings in some guests who were already looking for you.

  • Run ads and discounts at different times, or at least track them separately, so you know which one moved orders.
  • Set a daily or weekly budget cap before you start.
  • Measure cost per new guest, not cost per order, because ads you pay for on orders from regulars are wasted.
  • Check your rating before paying for visibility. Ads send more guests to your listing, and a weak rating turns them away. See how to improve ratings on delivery apps.

A decision checklist

Use these questions before launching or renewing any campaign.

  1. Is the contribution per promo order still positive after commission, discount, food, packaging and labor?
  2. Is the offer limited to slow days or times when the kitchen has room?
  3. Do you know your new-guest share and 30-day repeat rate from past campaigns?
  4. Is there a written stop rule, such as ending the campaign if fewer than one in five promo guests are new?
  5. Will the promotion run long enough to measure, but short enough to limit losses, such as two to four weeks?
  6. Is there a plan to invite new guests to order directly next time, within the platform's rules?

If the answer to the first question is no, the promotion is a cost of acquiring guests. That can still be a fair choice, but make it on purpose and cap the spend.

Turning promo guests into direct guests

The most valuable outcome of a delivery promotion is a guest who later orders from you directly, where you keep more of the order. 68% of delivery customers have used a third-party service in the past six months[7], so the apps are often where new guests first find you. Your packaging, the food and a simple invitation to your own ordering site, where platform rules allow it, can do the rest.

  • Make the first order perfect. Run a bag check and protect quote times during the promo window.
  • Include a printed card with your own ordering link if your platform agreement permits it.
  • Give direct orders a reason: a loyalty program, a pickup-only special or a family bundle that is not on the apps.

For how to do this without breaking platform terms, see moving delivery app customers to direct ordering.

Example: judging a campaign after 60 days

Example: the fictional pizza restaurant above runs its 20%-off promotion on Monday to Wednesday evenings for four weeks. It gets 180 promo orders. The portal shows 45% came from new guests. After 60 days, 22 of those new guests have ordered again, 15 of them at full price.

In this Example, the owner compares the contribution forgone on 180 promo orders with the contribution from the 15 full-price repeat guests and their likely future orders. The result is close to break-even, so instead of renewing the same offer, the owner tests a free dessert on orders over $35, which costs less per order and lifts basket size. The decision comes from the numbers, not from how busy the promo weeks felt.

Frequently asked questions

Are DoorDash or Uber Eats promotions worth it for restaurants?

Sometimes. They can bring in new guests, especially in slow periods, but each promo order carries the platform commission plus the discount you fund. Measure how many promo guests reorder at full price before you renew.

What is a good return on a delivery app promotion?

Judge it by contribution margin, not sales. A promotion pays when the margin from repeat orders by new guests covers the money lost or forgone on the promo orders themselves, within a time frame you choose in advance.

Should I run promotions during my busiest hours?

Usually not. Busy hours already fill the kitchen. Promotions work better on slow days and times, when spare capacity makes each extra order cheaper to produce.

Are sponsored listings the same as promotions?

No. Sponsored listings or ads pay for a better position in search results; promotions discount the order. Track them separately, because they reach different guests and carry different costs.

References

  1. National Restaurant Association (2025). Report: Takeout, drive-thru, delivery are more popular than ever (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. National Restaurant Association (2025). From Trend to Transformation: Off-Premises Dining Now Essential for Restaurant Consumers, Operators (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. National Restaurant Association (2025). From Trend to Transformation: Off-Premises Dining Now Essential for Restaurant Consumers, Operators (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. National Restaurant Association (2026). National Restaurant Association comments to the FTC on the Food Delivery Fees ANPRM (Project No. P267101) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. National Restaurant Association (2026). National Restaurant Association comments to the FTC on the Food Delivery Fees ANPRM (Project No. P267101) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. National Restaurant Association (2026). Restaurants remain resilient despite challenging business conditions (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. National Restaurant Association (2026). National Restaurant Association comments to the FTC on the Food Delivery Fees ANPRM (Project No. P267101) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo