Key takeaways
- When you take a tip credit, deductions for walkouts, breakage or cash register shortages take wages below the minimum wage and are not allowed[1].
- For any employee, deductions for items that mainly benefit the employer cannot reduce pay below the minimum wage or cut into overtime[2].
- An employee paid exactly the federal minimum cannot be charged for a required uniform at all[2]; California makes the employer pay for required uniforms[3].
- Prevent losses with process, not paycheck deductions: walkout procedures, breakage budgets and cash controls.
The short answer for most restaurants
Charging a server for a table that walked out, a cook for a dropped case of glasses or a cashier for a short drawer feels fair to many owners. In most restaurants it is illegal or close to it. Federal wage law treats these costs as the employer's business expenses, and it does not let you shift them onto employees if the result is pay below the minimum wage or reduced overtime. Many states go further and ban the deductions outright except in narrow cases.
Tipped employees are the clearest case. If you pay a cash wage as low as $2.13 an hour and count tips toward the $7.25 federal minimum[4], there is no room left for any deduction: the Labor Department says deductions for walkouts, breakage or cash register shortages reduce the employee's wages below the minimum wage[1].
Source: US Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division, 2026[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Minimum cash wage for tipped employees | $2.13 |
| Federal minimum wage | $7.25 |
How the federal rules work
The Labor Department's fact sheet on deductions explains the principle. Costs for items that are primarily for the employer's benefit, such as uniforms required by the employer, tools, damage to the employer's property by the employee or others, customer non-payment and theft, may not be deducted where the deduction would reduce the employee's earnings below the required minimum wage or overtime compensation[2]. The same fact sheet lists a minimum-wage cashier required to reimburse a cash drawer shortage, and tipped employees required to pay for customers who walk out, among examples of problems[2].
| Deduction | Non-tipped employee paid above minimum | Tipped employee with a tip credit | California |
|---|---|---|---|
| Customer walkout | Only down to the minimum wage for the workweek, if state law allows[2] | Not allowed: takes wages below minimum[1] | Only for a dishonest or willful act or gross negligence[3] |
| Breakage or damage | Only down to the minimum wage, if state law allows[2] | Not allowed[1] | Only for a dishonest or willful act or gross negligence[3] |
| Cash register shortage | Only down to the minimum wage, if state law allows[2] | Not allowed[1] | Only for a dishonest or willful act or gross negligence[3] |
| Required uniform | Not allowed at all for an employee paid the federal minimum; otherwise only down to the minimum[2] | Effectively not allowed | Employer must pay for a required uniform[3] |
Two more federal points matter. Tips belong to employees, and an employer may not keep any portion of them[5], so taking a walkout out of a server's tips is not a workaround. And an employer cannot avoid the limits by having the employee pay the amount back in cash instead of through payroll.
Uniforms: what you can and cannot charge
If an employee is paid $7.25 an hour, the employer may not make any deduction for the cost of a required uniform[2]. If the employee earns more, a deduction is allowed under federal law only to the extent it does not take pay below the minimum wage or into overtime, and it may be spread over several paydays as long as no workweek falls below the minimum[2]. State rules are often stricter: California requires the employer to pay for a uniform it requires[3].
Example: in a state that follows the federal rule, a fictional dishwasher earns $7.75 an hour for 30 hours, or $232.50 a week. The minimum for those hours is 30 x $7.25 = $217.50, so no more than $15.00 can be deducted that week. A $45 required uniform would have to be spread over at least three weeks, with written authorization, and in many states could not be deducted at all.
Many restaurants avoid the question by supplying shirts and aprons, laundering them, and letting staff wear their own black pants and non-slip shoes, which are usually treated as ordinary clothing rather than a uniform. If you require a specific branded item, budget for it as a business cost.
Preventing walkouts without touching pay
Watch exits
Seat parties where staff can see them, especially near patio exits and restrooms, and keep the host stand staffed during peak hours.
Present checks promptly
Train servers to present the check soon after dessert or the final drink, and to stay aware of tables that linger.
Pre-authorize bar tabs
Hold a card for open tabs and close tabs at a set time or amount.
Use pay-at-table devices
Handheld payment reduces the time a check sits unpaid on the table.
Have a walkout procedure
If a table leaves without paying, staff alert the manager and never chase or confront guests outside. The manager records the details and decides whether to report it.
Absorb the loss as the restaurant
Record walkouts as a cost of doing business and track them by section and shift to find patterns.
Script for a server who spots a table leaving: 'Manager to section four, please.' Then step back. Staff safety comes before a check, and the restaurant, not the server, carries the loss.
Breakage and shortages: better controls
- Budget for breakage: set a monthly allowance for glass and china and review it, rather than charging staff.
- Fix the causes: overloaded bus tubs, worn racks, slippery floors and crowded dish pits break more glassware than careless people do.
- Count drawers together: have the cashier and a manager count in and out with signatures, so shortages can be traced to a time and a cause.
- Limit access: one person per drawer per shift where possible, and drops to the safe above a set amount.
- Use cameras over cash points, with a posted notice where your state requires one.
- Handle suspected theft as a disciplinary or legal matter, documented and investigated, not as a pay deduction.
Where state law allows a deduction for a willful act or gross negligence, as in California's rule[3], the burden is on the employer to show it. In practice, very few cases meet that bar, and getting it wrong can turn a small loss into a wage claim with penalties.
Other deductions restaurants ask about
Walkouts and breakage are the famous cases, but restaurant payrolls see many other deductions. Each follows the same test: who mainly benefits from the item, does the employee agree in writing where required, and does the employee still receive at least the minimum wage and full overtime for every workweek.
- Staff meals: often allowed as a credit or deduction for the reasonable cost of meals the employee actually receives, but many states set strict limits and require voluntary agreement, and some tipped wage rules restrict meal credits.
- Comped or wrong orders: a server's ordering mistake is a cost of doing business; do not charge it to the server.
- Point of sale or card fees: federal rules allow deducting no more than the actual card processing fee from a card tip; anything more is a taking of tips.
- Training courses: required food handler or alcohol service courses are generally the employer's cost in many states, and some states require paid training time.
- Advances and loans: repayment by payroll deduction usually needs a written agreement and must respect minimum wage limits in each workweek.
- Equipment such as knives: if you require a specific tool, treat it as a business expense; if a cook chooses to buy premium knives, that is their own purchase.
If you have already been deducting
Many owners learn these rules after years of charging servers for walkouts or taking breakage out of a tip pool. The fix is to stop, calculate and repay. Pull payroll records for the recovery period in your state, list every deduction of the kinds described above, and calculate what each employee is owed, including any minimum wage shortfall the deduction created. Repay current employees through payroll with a clear explanation, and contact former employees where you can. Speak with an employment lawyer about how to present the repayment, and change the policy in writing so managers do not restart the practice.
Example: a fictional diner had charged servers for walkouts for two years, averaging about $40 a month per server across eight servers. The owner stopped immediately, repaid roughly $7,680 through payroll over two pay periods with a note explaining the change, and added walkouts to the monthly loss report instead.
Check your state's rule
State rules range from following the federal floor to banning almost all deductions except taxes, benefits the employee chooses and court-ordered garnishments. Many require written, voluntary authorization for any deduction, and some require that authorization for each deduction separately. Before making any deduction from a restaurant employee's pay, check your state labor department's guidance, get written authorization where required and confirm the employee still earns at least the minimum wage for every workweek.
Related reading: service charge distribution state rules and restaurant recordkeeping: what to keep and how long.
Frequently asked questions
Can a restaurant make a server pay for a walkout?
If you take a tip credit, no: the deduction takes wages below the minimum wage. Even without a tip credit, many states ban it, and federal law never lets it reduce pay below the minimum.
Can I deduct broken dishes from an employee's paycheck?
Generally not if it takes pay below the minimum wage, and never from tipped employees paid with a tip credit. Many states ban it except for willful acts or gross negligence.
Can I charge employees for uniforms?
Not for an employee paid the federal minimum, and California requires employers to pay for required uniforms. Elsewhere, any deduction cannot take pay below the minimum.
Can I take a cash shortage out of a cashier's tips?
No. Tips belong to employees and cannot be kept by the employer, so deducting a shortage from tips is not allowed.
References
US Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division (2026). Fact Sheet #15: Tipped Employees Under the Fair Labor Standards Act (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division (2009). Fact Sheet #16: Deductions From Wages for Uniforms and Other Facilities Under the FLSA (opens in a new tab) ↑
California Department of Industrial Relations, Labor Commissioner's Office (2026). Deductions: Frequently Asked Questions (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division (2026). Minimum Wages for Tipped Employees (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute (Cornell Law School) (2026). 29 U.S. Code § 203 - Definitions (Fair Labor Standards Act) (opens in a new tab) ↑