Key takeaways
- On August 23, 2024 the Fifth Circuit vacated the Department of Labor's 2021 tip credit rule, which had capped supporting side work at 20% of a workweek and 30 continuous minutes[1].
- The older dual jobs principle still matters: no tip credit can be taken for hours an employee spends in a separate, non-tipped occupation[2].
- Related duties, such as setting tables or making coffee, can be part of a tipped occupation even though they do not produce tips themselves[1][2].
- Until the law settles, keep side work tied to the server's job and reasonable in amount, and pay full minimum wage for anything that is really another job.
Why side work matters for the tip credit
When you take a tip credit, you pay a tipped employee as little as $2.13 an hour in cash and count up to $5.12 an hour of tips toward the $7.25 federal minimum[3]. That arrangement only makes sense for time spent in the tipped job. Every restaurant also asks servers and bartenders to do work that does not earn tips directly: rolling silverware, cutting lemons, restocking stations, cleaning before close. The legal question is how much of that work can be paid at the tipped cash wage, and which tasks are really a different job.
Source: US Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division, 2026[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Hour in tipped occupation (with tip credit) | $2.13 |
| Hour in separate non-tipped job | $7.25 |
The difference per hour is large. An hour of genuine non-tipped work paid at the tipped cash wage instead of the full minimum leaves $5.12 unpaid under federal rules[3], and more in states with higher minimums. Across a team and a few years, that becomes a significant back-pay claim.
How the rules got here
The Fifth Circuit's 2024 opinion summarizes the history. In 1967 the Department of Labor issued its dual jobs regulation, which distinguished a hotel maintenance worker who also serves as a waiter, who is employed in two occupations and is a tipped employee only for the waiter work, from a waitress who spends part of her time cleaning and setting tables, toasting bread, making coffee and occasionally washing dishes or glasses, whose related duties need not by themselves be directed toward producing tips[1].
In 1988 the department added its 80/20 guidance to its Field Operations Handbook, allowing a maximum of 20 percent of an employee's time on non-tipped activities related to the tipped occupation for the employer to claim the full tip credit[1]. The guidance was withdrawn and restored several times after 2009 as administrations changed[1]. In 2021 the department wrote a final rule that sorted work into three groups, tip-producing, directly supporting, and work not part of the tipped occupation, and barred the credit for supporting work beyond 20 percent of the workweek or beyond 30 continuous minutes[1].
| Year | Development | Effect for restaurants |
|---|---|---|
| 1967 | Dual jobs regulation | No credit for a separate occupation; related duties allowed |
| 1988 | 80/20 guidance in the Field Operations Handbook | Related side work limited to 20% of time for the full credit |
| 2009 onward | Guidance withdrawn and restored | Uncertainty; courts split on how to apply it |
| 2021 | Final rule: 80/20 plus a 30-minute limit | Detailed time tracking of supporting work |
| August 23, 2024 | Fifth Circuit vacates the 2021 rule | The 80/20/30 rule no longer stands as a regulation |
On August 23, 2024, in Restaurant Law Center v. Department of Labor, the court held the 2021 rule contrary to the statute's text and arbitrary and capricious, reversed the lower court and vacated the rule[1].
What still applies today
Vacating the 2021 rule removed the bright-line 20 percent and 30-minute limits, but it did not create a free-for-all. The statute still defines a tipped employee by the occupation in which they are engaged[4], and the Department of Labor's current fact sheet still states the two core ideas from 1967. First, when an employee works in two occupations, such as a server who also works maintenance shifts, no tip credit can be taken for the hours in the non-tipped occupation[2]. Second, related duties in a tipped occupation need not by themselves be directed toward producing tips[2].
So the test today is about the nature of the work more than a stopwatch. Is the task part of the server's or bartender's job, or is it really the job of a cook, a dishwasher or a cleaner? Courts outside the Fifth Circuit may still look at how much time is spent on related tasks, and state laws can impose their own limits, so a large and growing share of side work remains a risk even without the federal rule.
Sorting side work tasks
| Task | Usual classification | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Rolling silverware, folding napkins | Related duty of the tipped job | Supports guest service on the shift |
| Setting and resetting tables | Related duty of the tipped job | Supports guest service on the shift |
| Brewing coffee and iced tea for service | Related duty of the tipped job | Supports guest service on the shift |
| Restocking the server station | Related duty of the tipped job | Supports guest service on the shift |
| Cutting garnishes for the bar during service | Related duty of the tipped job | Supports guest service on the shift |
| Preparing salads, desserts or sauces from scratch for the kitchen | Separate occupation | Cook or prep work |
| Washing dishes in the dish pit | Separate occupation | Dishwasher work |
| Deep cleaning restrooms, walk-ins or kitchen floors | Separate occupation | Janitorial work |
| Pre-opening shifts with no guests, doing only prep | Separate occupation | No guests; pay at full minimum |
The middle ground is where judgment matters: a server who occasionally washes glasses during a rush is doing related work, while a server scheduled for two hours of dish duty every Monday is working a second job for those two hours.
Bartenders, bussers and counter service
Servers get most of the attention, but the same analysis applies to other tipped roles. A bartender who cuts fruit, restocks the well and polishes glassware for the bar is doing related work. A bartender who spends the afternoon receiving and shelving the restaurant's entire beverage delivery, or doing inventory for the kitchen, is closer to a stockroom job for those hours.
Bussers and food runners are tipped in many restaurants through tip-outs or pools, and their side work often overlaps with dishwashing. Clearing tables and bringing bus tubs to the dish pit is part of bussing; running the dish machine for an hour is a dishwasher's job. In counter-service concepts where tips come from a screen prompt, the line between tipped and non-tipped work is blurrier, so many operators avoid the tip credit there altogether.
Safe practices while the law settles
- Write a side work list for each tipped role and keep it to tasks that support that role's service.
- Move kitchen prep, dish and deep-cleaning tasks to non-tipped staff, or pay full minimum wage when tipped staff do them.
- Create a separate job code at full minimum wage for any non-tipped job a tipped employee works, and require clock-in under the right code.
- Avoid pre-opening or post-close blocks made up only of side work at the tipped cash wage; if there are no guests, pay full minimum.
- Keep side work reasonable in amount; if servers report spending a large share of their shift on side work, rebalance duties.
- Check your state law, which may set its own limits or bar the tip credit entirely.
- Review the side work list whenever you change your service model, such as moving to counter ordering.
Example: a Monday prep shift
Example: a fictional diner in a state that follows the federal tip credit schedules two servers each Monday from 2 p.m. to 5 p.m., before dinner, to cut vegetables for the line, portion dressings and scrub the walk-in. No guests are seated. Both are paid the $2.13 cash wage for those hours. Those tasks are cook and cleaning work, not server side work, so the restaurant should treat the three hours as a separate non-tipped job paid at least $7.25 an hour. For two servers over a year, the shortfall is $5.12 times 3 hours times 2 servers times 52 weeks, or $1,597.44, before any state rate differences, damages or penalties.
Example, continued: the owner sets up a prep job code at full minimum wage, has the servers clock in under it on Mondays, and keeps only table setting and station restocking in the servers' 4 p.m. to 5 p.m. side work.
The cost of getting it wrong
Side work claims are usually brought as back-pay claims for the difference between the cash wage paid and the full minimum for the disputed hours. Federal civil money penalties for repeated or willful minimum wage or overtime violations are $2,515 per violation for penalties assessed on or after January 16, 2026[5]. Add state penalties, liquidated damages and legal fees, and a practice that saved a few dollars per shift can cost far more.
Side work review checklist
Shadow a full shift
Watch what tipped staff actually do before, during and after service, not what the list says.
Classify every task
Mark each task as related to the tipped job or as a separate occupation.
Fix the schedule
Move separate-occupation tasks to non-tipped staff or a full-minimum job code.
Update payroll codes
Make sure the POS and time clock force the right code for each type of work.
Train managers
Explain why they cannot send servers to the dish pit at the tipped wage on a slow night.
Recheck twice a year
Repeat the shadow review and update the list as the menu and service style change.
Frequently asked questions
Is the 80/20 rule still in effect?
The Department of Labor's 2021 rule, which set the 20 percent and 30-minute limits, was vacated by the Fifth Circuit on August 23, 2024. The older principle that no tip credit applies to a separate non-tipped occupation still applies, and some courts and states may still look at time spent on side work.
Can I pay servers the tipped wage for rolling silverware?
Rolling silverware and similar tasks are usually related duties of a server. Keep them reasonable in amount, and do not stack long blocks of side work with no guests at the tipped wage.
What counts as a dual job?
A separate occupation, such as a server who also works scheduled shifts as a dishwasher, cook or cleaner. No tip credit can be taken for the hours in the non-tipped occupation.
Do state laws have their own side work limits?
Some states set their own rules or do not allow a tip credit at all. Check your state labor department before relying on the federal position.
References
United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit (2024). Restaurant Law Center v. U.S. Department of Labor, No. 23-50562 (opinion, August 23, 2024) (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division (2026). Fact Sheet #15: Tipped Employees Under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division (2026). Minimum Wages for Tipped Employees (state and federal table) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute (Cornell Law School), US Code (2026). 29 U.S. Code § 203 - Definitions (Fair Labor Standards Act) (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division (2026). Civil Money Penalty Inflation Adjustments (opens in a new tab) ↑