Key takeaways
- A fee on a direct online order is any mandatory charge added to menu prices: service, convenience, small-order, packaging or delivery.
- In California, restaurant mandatory fees are allowed only if clearly and conspicuously displayed wherever prices are shown[1].
- The FTC's 2025 fees rule covers live-event tickets and short-term lodging, not restaurants, but state and local rules can still apply[2].
- Whatever the law, name the fee, show the amount early, say what it pays for and never imply it is a tip if it is not.
What counts as a fee on a direct order
When a guest orders from your own website or app, the bill can include several charges on top of menu prices. Each one should have a name the guest understands and a reason you can explain in one sentence.
| Charge | What it usually covers | How to describe it to guests |
|---|---|---|
| Service fee | Ordering platform, card processing, packaging or staff costs | “A 3% service fee supports our online ordering and packaging costs.” (Example wording) |
| Convenience fee | Cost of the online channel itself | Name what it pays for, or rename it as a service fee |
| Delivery fee | Driver time and mileage | Show by zone before checkout |
| Small-order fee | Orders below a minimum that do not cover delivery | State the minimum next to the fee |
| Packaging or bag fee | Containers, bags, local bag charges | Note if a local law requires the bag charge |
| Tip | Optional gratuity for staff | Always optional, always separate from fees |
Guests are more likely to accept a fee they can see early and understand than one that appears at the final screen with a vague name.
Why restaurants add fees to direct orders
Online orders have costs that dine-in orders do not: the ordering platform, card processing, containers, bags, labels and, for delivery, driver time. More than 9 in 10 operators cite food, labor, insurance, energy and swipe fees as significant challenges[3]. Menu prices for food away from home rose 3.5% in the 12 months to September 2026[4], and many owners prefer a fee to another round of menu increases.
Marketplace apps show the same pressure in another form. Two in three restaurants say the average fee they pay delivery platforms is 15% to 29.9% of the transaction[5], and most operators now charge more for items ordered through a third-party app than for dine-in or takeout[6].
Source: National Restaurant Association, 2026[6]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Limited-service | 83% |
| Full-service | 66% |
On your own channel you have a choice: build those costs into item prices, or show them as a separate, clearly named fee. Both are legitimate. What causes trouble is a fee that is hidden, misnamed or presented as something it is not.
What the rules say
Fee rules are mostly set at the state and local level, and they change. Treat this section as a starting point and check your own state and city before you launch or change a fee.
- California: under the state's hidden-fees law as amended, restaurant and bar mandatory fees are exempt only if the fee is clearly and conspicuously displayed wherever prices are shown[1]. In practice, that means on the online menu and the checkout, not only on the receipt.
- Federal: the FTC's Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees took effect on May 12, 2025. The FTC says businesses selling live-event tickets and short-term lodging are covered[2]. Restaurants are not named in its coverage, but that does not override state or local rules.
- Cities: some cities regulate delivery and service charges, especially on marketplace apps. Check your city consumer affairs or licensing office.
- Tips and service charges in payroll: how you treat a mandatory charge in payroll is a separate question from how you show it to guests. See tips on takeout orders for the distribution side.
If you sell in more than one state or city, use the strictest rule you are subject to as your standard everywhere. It keeps your website and staff answers consistent.
A disclosure checklist for your ordering site
Name the fee plainly
Use “service fee” or “delivery fee,” not “operations surcharge” or “admin.” Avoid names that sound like a government charge.
Show it where prices appear
Put a short line on the online menu page, near the top, stating the fee and the percentage or amount.
Show it again before payment
List the fee as its own line at checkout, before the guest enters card details.
Say what it pays for
One sentence is enough. If it does not go to staff, do not imply that it does.
Keep it out of the tip line
The tip line should be optional and clearly separate, with no default amount that looks like a fee.
Match every channel
Phone staff, receipts and your website should describe the fee in the same words.
Review when anything changes
New platform, new state or city, new fee amount or a guest complaint pattern.
Wording that works, and wording that backfires
Good disclosure is short and specific. These are examples to adapt, not legal language.
- Works: “Online orders include a 3% service fee that helps cover packaging and online ordering costs. Tips are optional and go to our team.” (Example)
- Works: “Delivery fee: Zone A and Zone B shown at checkout. Orders under the minimum include a small-order fee.” (Example)
- Backfires: a fee called “kitchen appreciation” that is not paid to the kitchen.
- Backfires: a fee that appears only on the final payment screen with no earlier mention.
- Backfires: a default tip pre-selected beside a service fee, which reads as charging twice.
Example: choosing between a fee and a price change
Example: a fictional family Italian restaurant takes about a fifth of its sales through its own online ordering. The owner adds up the online channel's monthly platform charges, card processing and packaging and finds they equal roughly 4% of online sales.
In this Example, option one is a 4% service fee shown on the menu page and at checkout. Option two is raising online menu prices by about 4% while keeping dine-in prices the same. The owner picks option one for transparency, names it “online service fee,” adds the explanation line, and trains the host to answer “It covers packaging and our online ordering system; it is not a tip.”
After two months, the owner checks complaints and average order size. If complaints about the fee are rare and order size holds, the fee stays. If guests push back, the owner moves the cost into online menu prices instead.
Pickup, delivery and catering need different fees
One fee for every order type is simple, but it rarely matches your costs. Pickup orders use packaging and the ordering system. Delivery orders add driver time and distance. Catering adds setup, serving equipment and sometimes staff on site. Treat each one on its own terms.
- Pickup: if you charge anything, a small service fee tied to packaging and ordering costs is the easiest to explain.
- Delivery: show the delivery fee by zone before checkout, and keep it separate from any service fee so guests can see what each covers.
- Small orders: if a minimum applies, state it next to the delivery fee rather than surprising guests with a small-order fee at the last step.
- Catering: state service charges, delivery and setup on the written quote, and say whether any part goes to staff.
Keep the names consistent across order types. A guest who sees “service fee” on pickup and “operations charge” on delivery will assume the second is something different.
How to test a fee before rolling it out
A fee change touches revenue, guest trust and staff answers at the same time. Run it as a short, measured test rather than a permanent switch.
Pick a test period
Four to six weeks covers enough weekends to see a pattern.
Record the baseline
Note online orders per week, average order size, repeat-guest share and fee-related complaints before the change.
Launch with full disclosure
Update the menu page, checkout, receipts and staff script on the same day.
Track complaints by channel
Phone, online reviews, email and in person. Note the exact words guests use.
Decide with the numbers
Keep, adjust or remove the fee based on the change in orders, order size and complaints, not on the loudest single complaint.
Staff answers for the most common questions
Guests ask about fees on the phone and at pickup. Give staff three short answers so nobody guesses.
- “What is the service fee?” It covers packaging and online ordering costs, and it is shown on our menu page and at checkout.
- “Does it go to the staff?” Answer truthfully based on your policy. If it does not, say so and point to the optional tip.
- “Can you remove it?” Explain your policy. If managers can waive it for a complaint, say who can and when.
For very large orders, state any packaging or service charge in the written confirmation, as covered in how to handle large to-go orders.
Frequently asked questions
Can restaurants charge a service fee on online orders?
In most places, yes, if the fee is disclosed clearly and not misleading. Some states and cities set specific rules. California, for example, exempts restaurant mandatory fees from its hidden-fees law only when they are clearly and conspicuously displayed wherever prices appear.
Is a service fee the same as a tip?
No, unless you treat it that way in payroll and say so. A mandatory service fee is generally the restaurant's revenue. Tell guests plainly what it pays for, and keep the tip line separate if you offer one.
Does the FTC junk fees rule apply to restaurants?
The FTC's Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees, effective May 12, 2025, covers businesses selling live-event tickets and short-term lodging. Restaurants are not named in it, but state laws and local rules can still apply.
Should I raise menu prices instead of adding a fee?
It depends on your guests and your market. Prices built into the menu are simpler to explain. A clearly labeled fee keeps menu prices comparable to dine-in but needs careful disclosure and staff answers.
References
California Department of Justice, Office of the Attorney General (2024). SB 478 - Hidden Fees (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2025). The Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees: Frequently Asked Questions (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Restaurant Association (2026). Persistent Cost Increases and Enduring Demand Will Shape the Restaurant Industry in 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Consumer Price Index: series CUUR0000SEFV (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Restaurant Association (2026). National Restaurant Association comments to the FTC on the Food Delivery Fees ANPRM (Project No. P267101) (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Restaurant Association (2026). National Restaurant Association comments to the FTC on the Food Delivery Fees ANPRM (Project No. P267101) (opens in a new tab) ↑