Key takeaways
- A manager is exempt from federal overtime only if paid on a salary basis of at least $684 a week[1] and their duties meet the executive test[2].
- The duties test: primary duty is management, they customarily and regularly direct two or more full-time employees or the equivalent, and they can hire or fire or their recommendations carry particular weight[2].
- Managers can serve guests and cook alongside staff and stay exempt, but a working supervisor whose main job is production work is not exempt[3].
- A salary alone never makes someone exempt; many restaurant shift managers should be paid hourly with overtime.
Why this exemption causes so many claims
Restaurant management is long-hours work. Food service managers often work evenings, weekends and holidays, and some work more than 40 hours a week[4]. Paying a salary and treating the role as exempt from overtime is common, and often correct for general managers. The problems start when the same treatment is extended to assistant managers, kitchen managers and shift leads whose day looks more like a cook's or a server's than a manager's.
Pay levels make the stakes clear. Food service managers earned a median of $69,390 a year in 2025[5], or $33.36 an hour[6], while first-line supervisors of food preparation and serving workers earned a median of $21.19 an hour[7]. A supervisor paid a modest salary for 55 or 60 hours a week can end up earning less per hour than the people they supervise, and if the exemption does not apply, every hour over 40 is owed at time and a half.
Test one: salary basis and salary level
Federal regulations require an exempt executive to be compensated on a salary basis at a rate of not less than $684 a week[1], which is $35,568 over a year. Salary basis means a predetermined amount paid each pay period that is not reduced because of variations in the quality or quantity of work. Docking a manager's pay for a slow week or a partial-day absence can break the salary basis and the exemption with it, so check deductions with your payroll provider before making any.
The $684 figure is the federal floor. Several states set higher salary levels for exempt employees, often tied to the state minimum wage, so a salary that satisfies federal law can still fail state law. Confirm your state's threshold before setting manager salaries.[1]
Source: Legal Information Institute (Cornell Law School), eCFR, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 40 hours | $17.1 |
| 50 hours | $13.68 |
| 60 hours | $11.4 |
Test two: the executive duties test
The Department of Labor's executive exemption fact sheet sets out the duties test[2]. All three parts must be met.
- Primary duty is management. The employee's primary duty must be managing the enterprise or a customarily recognized department or subdivision, judged by the character of the job as a whole[2].
- Directs two or more employees. They must customarily and regularly direct the work of two or more other full-time employees or their equivalent, where customarily and regularly means greater than occasional but less than constant[2].
- Hiring and firing authority. They must have authority to hire or fire, or their suggestions and recommendations on hiring, firing, advancement, promotion or other changes of status must be given particular weight[2].
Primary duty means the principal, main, major or most important duty the employee performs[2]. Time spent is a useful guide, but it is not the only factor. What matters is whether the business relies on this person to run the operation, and whether they actually exercise that authority day to day.
Managers who also work the floor or line
Restaurant managers rarely just manage. The regulation on concurrent duties recognizes this: performing exempt and nonexempt work at the same time does not disqualify an employee from the executive exemption if the other requirements are met[3]. Its example is an assistant manager who waits on customers, prepares food, restocks and cleans; the regulation says such a manager can supervise employees and serve customers at the same time without losing the exemption[3].
The same regulation draws the line. A relief or working supervisor whose primary duty is nonexempt production work does not become exempt just because they occasionally direct coworkers, for example when the exempt supervisor is absent[3]. An exempt executive generally decides when to do nonexempt work and remains responsible for the unit's results; a nonexempt worker is directed to do the work[3].
| Role | Typical reality | Likely status |
|---|---|---|
| General manager | Runs the restaurant, hires and fires, owns results | Exempt if salary test met |
| Assistant general manager | Runs shifts, directs staff, hiring input followed | Often exempt if salary test met |
| Kitchen manager or chef | Directs cooks, orders, schedules, hiring input | Often exempt if salary test met |
| Shift manager or key holder | Works a station most of the shift, opens and closes | Often nonexempt; pay hourly with overtime |
| Lead line cook | Cooks all shift, guides newer cooks | Nonexempt |
| Bar manager | Orders, schedules bartenders, also bartends | Depends on authority and primary duty |
Misclassification traps
- The salaried shift lead: paid a salary above $684, but spends almost every shift on the line with no real hiring role.[1]
- The manager in name only: has the title and keys, but every hiring decision is made by the owner without asking them.
- Too few people to direct: a manager at a small cafe who directs only one part-time employee does not meet the two-or-more test.
- The docked salary: a manager's pay is cut for a day off or a slow week, undermining the salary basis.
- The state gap: the salary meets the federal level but not the higher state level.
- The promotion without change: a server promoted to salaried manager who still works a full section every night.
Example: a misclassified shift manager
Example: a fictional burger restaurant pays a shift manager a salary of $800 a week and treats the role as exempt. She works 55 hours most weeks, spends nearly all of it cooking on the grill or running the register, and has no hiring input. An audit concludes she is nonexempt. If her salary is treated as pay for 40 hours, her regular rate is $20.00 an hour and her overtime rate is $30.00. Fifteen overtime hours a week come to $450 in unpaid overtime per week, or more than $23,000 over a year, before any damages or state penalties.
Example, continued: the owner converts the role to hourly at $20.00 with overtime, schedules her for 45 hours, and hires a part-time cook to cover the remaining shifts. Total cost rises modestly, the legal exposure ends, and her pay now reflects the hours she works.
Making hourly managers work
Paying shift managers hourly is not a demotion if it is presented well. An hourly manager is paid for every hour, including the late close that runs long and the inventory count on Sunday morning. Many prefer it once they see the numbers.
- Set a meaningful hourly rate that reflects the responsibility, above the rate of the staff they lead.
- Add a shift differential for opening or closing as manager on duty.
- Plan schedules around 40 to 45 hours, and approve extra hours in advance where possible.
- Offer a bonus tied to measurable results, such as labor cost or health inspection scores; nondiscretionary bonuses must be included in the regular rate for overtime.
- Keep a clear path to a salaried exempt role with real hiring authority, so ambitious leads can see where the job leads.
Records that support an exemption
If a classification is challenged, the employer has to show the exemption applies. Keep a current job description that matches reality, examples of the manager's hiring and firing recommendations and how they were acted on, schedules showing the employees they directed, and payroll records proving a consistent salary with no improper deductions. Review these each year and whenever the role changes, because a manager who was exempt at a busy flagship may not be exempt after moving to a small location with two employees.
Classify your managers in five steps
List every salaried role
Include general, assistant, kitchen, bar and shift managers at every location.
Check the salary
Confirm each salary meets $684 a week and your state's level, and that no improper deductions are made.[1]
Document real duties
Write down what each person actually does over a typical week, including hours on the floor or line.
Test hiring authority
Confirm whether their recommendations are actually sought and followed, with examples.
Reclassify where needed
Move roles that fail to hourly pay with overtime, and get advice on any back pay owed.
When in doubt, pay hourly with overtime. A well-paid hourly manager costs a little more in busy weeks; a misclassified salaried manager can cost years of back overtime.
Frequently asked questions
Do restaurant managers get overtime?
Only if they are nonexempt. A manager is exempt from federal overtime only when paid a salary of at least $684 a week and their duties meet the executive test. Check your state's rules too.
Can a salaried manager work on the line?
Yes, an exempt manager can cook or serve alongside staff, as long as management remains their primary duty and the other tests are met.
Is an assistant manager exempt?
It depends on duties. If their primary duty is management, they regularly direct two or more full-time employees or the equivalent, and their hiring recommendations carry particular weight, they can be exempt.
What is the salary threshold for exempt managers?
The federal regulation sets $684 a week. Many states set higher levels.
References
Legal Information Institute (Cornell Law School), eCFR (2026). 29 CFR § 541.600 - Amount of salary required (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division (2024). Fact Sheet #17B: Exemption for Executive Employees Under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute (Cornell Law School), eCFR (2026). 29 CFR § 541.106 - Concurrent duties (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Food Service Managers (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Food Service Managers (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025 national estimate: Food service managers median hourly wage (series OEUN000000000000011905108) (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025 national estimate: First-line supervisors of food preparation and serving workers median hourly wage (series OEUN000000000000035101208) (opens in a new tab) ↑