Key takeaways
- Phone calls were the second most reported way scammers made contact in 2024[2], with the highest median loss of any contact method[1].
- Every restaurant scam call has the same shape: an authority, a deadline and an unusual way to pay. The fix is one rule, not instinct.
- Never verify a caller on the number they give or the one on caller ID; scammers fake caller ID[3]. Call the number you already hold.
- No real business or agency asks to be paid in gift cards[4]; a host who hears that phrase can end the call.
- Refund only to the original payment method, and never send back “the difference” on an overpaid order[5].
Why scammers ring the host stand
A restaurant's number is printed on the door, the menu, every listing and every delivery bag, and it is answered by whoever is nearest. On a Tuesday afternoon that may be a host in their second week, polishing menus, with the manager in the walk-in. Scammers know this. They call with an authority the host can't check, a deadline that doesn't leave time to ask, and a payment method nobody at the stand would normally touch.
The numbers say phone scams are not small. Phone calls were the second most commonly reported contact method for fraud in 2024, after email[2]. Among reports that named how the scammer made contact, the median loss when it started with a phone call was $1,500, higher than for texts, email, social media or websites[1]. Impostors were the most reported fraud category, with 845,806 reports and $2.95 billion lost[1]. Those are consumer reports to the FTC; losses at businesses aren't broken out, but the scripts are the same ones that land at the host stand.
This guide covers the calls that try to take money or account access. The everyday nuisance calls, robocalls and vendor pitches have their own playbook in spam, robocalls and vendor pitches at the host stand. The two belong together in host training: one keeps the line clear, the other keeps the cash drawer and the accounts safe.
Six calls and the check that stops each one
| Scam | How the call opens | The tell | The one check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fake inspector or licensing office | “County health department. You have an unpaid reinspection fee and we close you at five.” | Payment by phone today, threat of closure | Call the health department on the number from its website or your last inspection report |
| Utility shut-off | “Your power is being cut in 45 minutes for an overdue balance.” | Gift cards, payment app, crypto or a card read out now | Call the number printed on your last bill |
| Listing or directory seller | “Your Google listing will be suspended unless we verify it today.” | Asks for payment or a code sent to your phone | Owner logs in to the Business Profile directly |
| Overpaid order | Large catering order paid by check, then “we sent too much, refund the difference to our planner” | Refund to someone or something other than the original payment | Refund only to the original payment, after funds clear |
| The “owner” calling | “It's Mike, I'm stuck at the bank, buy three gift cards and read me the numbers.” | Urgent favor, secrecy, gift cards | Call the owner back on the number in the staff contact list |
| Supplier bank change | “Your produce supplier has a new account for this week's invoice.” | New payment details by phone or email | Call the supplier's rep on the number you already have |
Look at the last column. None of the checks asks a host to judge whether a caller sounds real. Each one moves the conversation to a number the restaurant already holds. That is deliberate. The FTC's advice to small businesses is blunt: scammers often fake their phone numbers, so don't trust caller ID[3]. Spoofing caller ID to defraud someone is illegal under federal law[6], but the law is no help at four on a Tuesday when the screen shows the utility's real number.
Fake inspectors and government callers
Government impostors threaten the thing an owner fears most. The FTC's small business guide describes callers who claim to be government agents and threaten to suspend business licenses, impose fines or sue[3]. People reported losing $789 million to government impostor scams in 2024, $171 million more than the year before[2]. For a restaurant the costume is usually the health department, the liquor authority, the fire marshal or the state tax office, and the ask is a fee, a fine or a “pre-inspection” deposit, payable now.
Hosts should never be the ones deciding whether an inspection notice is real. They take a name, the agency, a case or permit number if offered, and a callback number, and say a manager will return the call. The manager then calls the agency on a number they looked up themselves: the one on the agency's website, the last inspection report or your permit. If the caller refuses to give anything that the agency can look up, the call has answered its own question.
Host script: “I'm not able to handle that, but our manager will call the department back today. Can I take your name and a case number?” If the caller pushes for payment: “I can't take or make payments on this line. The manager will call the department directly.” Then end the call.
Since April 1, 2024 the FTC's impersonation rule has given the agency stronger tools against people who pose as government agencies and businesses[7]. It helps after the fact. It does not stop the next call, which is why the rule at the stand matters more than the rule in Washington.
Utility shut-off threats
The shut-off call works on restaurants because the threat is real in a way it isn't for most businesses. A dining room without power on a Friday is a lost night and a walk-in full of product at risk. The FTC describes the pattern exactly: callers who say they are from the utility and that gas, electric or water service is about to be interrupted because of a late bill that doesn't exist[3]. The deadline is always short, and payment is always unusual: a gift card, a payment app, cryptocurrency or a card number read over the phone.
- Caller
- Your team
01Caller
Threat with a deadline
“Power goes off in 45 minutes unless the balance is paid.”
02Caller
Payment demand
Gift cards, a payment app, crypto, or a card number read out now.
03Your team
Host reads the scam card
“Our manager will call the utility back on the number we have.”
04Your team
Manager calls known number
The number on the last bill or the account login, never one the caller gives.
05Your team
Logged and reported
Note in the manager log, warning at pre-shift, report to the FTC.
Example. The host's job ends at step three: no host decides whether a bill is real.
Gift cards are the giveaway. The FTC puts it plainly: no real business or government agency will ever tell you to buy a gift card to pay them, and it lists utility companies among the impostors who ask[4]. Train hosts to treat the words “gift card” in any payment demand as the end of the call. Bank transfers deserve the same suspicion: they accounted for about 40 percent of reported losses to government and business impostors in 2023[7].
Listing sellers and verification codes
The listing call comes in two flavors. One sells something: a premium placement, a “guaranteed first page”, a directory entry. The FTC warns that phony directory and advertising sellers may offer a free listing or say they only want to confirm your details, and the big bill follows later[3]. The other is quieter and more dangerous: a caller who says they need to verify your listing and asks the host to read back a code that just arrived by text. That code is often the key to your account.
Google does make automated calls and sends texts to confirm business details such as opening hours, and it says it will never ask a business for payment to stay on Google[8]. Payment requests and code requests are both outside what a host should ever do on the phone. The owner or manager logs in to the Business Profile directly to check its status. What legitimate automated calls from Google sound like is covered in when Google calls your restaurant.
Extend the code rule to everything: delivery tablets, the POS, payroll, the bank. A real support line for any of them can be reached from inside the app or from the number on your contract, and nobody on an incoming call needs a code from your phone.
Refund and overpayment tricks
Catering and large orders attract a slower scam. An event planner books a big order, pays by check or card for more than the total, then calls with an apology: they overpaid, could you send the difference to their caterer, their driver or a different card. The FTC's description of fake-check scams is the same story: a buyer “accidentally” overpays and asks for the balance back, the funds can show in your account before the check is discovered to be fake, which can take weeks, and you pay the bank back[5]. With a stolen card, the chargeback arrives later and takes the whole amount.
- Refund only to the original payment method, never to a different card, a payment app or a third party.
- Never send back “the difference”. Cancel the payment and ask the customer to pay the correct amount.
- Wait for funds to clear before refunding anything paid by check.
- Hold catering orders where the contact won't give a business name, an address you can check, or a callback number that answers.
These rules belong in your written refund and remake policy, so a host can point to it instead of arguing. Red flags for card fraud on takeout and catering orders are covered in stolen-card orders, and gift card schemes in gift card fraud and scams. In the three-restaurant example, catering inquiries reach one events manager as complete leads, which also means one person sees every unusual payment request.
When the caller says they're the owner
The cruelest version targets loyalty. A caller says they are the owner or the regional manager, they are stuck somewhere, and they need the host to buy gift cards, read out a code or open the safe for a courier. The voice may even sound right: the FTC notes that scammers posing as friends or relatives in an emergency sometimes use voice cloning[4]. A new host who wants to be helpful is the ideal target.
Give staff permission, in writing, to hang up on the owner. The rule is simple: any request for money, cards, codes or cash that arrives by phone is confirmed by calling the owner back on the number in the staff contact list. A real owner will be pleased the rule worked. Put this on day one of host training, because it is new hosts who get this call.
The scam card for the host stand
Fake inspector
Manager calls the agency on the number from its website or your last report
Utility shut-off
Manager calls the number printed on the last bill
Listing seller
Owner logs in directly; Google never asks for payment to stay listed[8]
Overpaid order
Refund only to the original payment, after funds clear
The owner calling
Call back on the number in the staff contact list
Supplier bank change
Call the rep on the number you already have
Print it, laminate it, tape it beside the phone.
Host stand rules. 1) I never pay, buy gift cards or move money because of a phone call. 2) I never read out a code sent to our phone or email. 3) I never give out card, bank, POS or delivery-app details. 4) Anyone who threatens a shutdown, fine or closure gets: “Our manager will call you back on the number we have on file.” 5) If the caller says they're the owner, I call the owner back. 6) I write every one of these calls in the manager log.
Set the defenses up in one afternoon
Build the verified numbers sheet
Utility account numbers and the service lines from your bills, the health department, liquor authority, landlord, POS and payment processor support, each delivery platform's merchant support, your suppliers' reps and the owner's mobile. Keep it in the manager office, not at the stand.
Write the payment rule down
No payment, refund, gift card purchase or transfer is made because of an incoming call, by anyone, without a callback to a number on the sheet.
Lock down the codes
Send verification codes for the listing, the POS and the delivery tablets to a manager's phone or email, not the host stand line.
Train it in two pre-shifts
Read the scam card aloud, role-play the shut-off call and the fake-owner call, and have each host say the callback line once. New hires get it in their first shift, alongside phone training.
Log and report
Every scam attempt goes in the manager log with the time, the number shown and what was asked. Report attempts to the FTC through its ReportFraud site, and warn the team at the next pre-shift.
The same boundaries apply to anything that answers your phone. If an SI Employee covers your overflow or after-hours calls, it answers only from the information you approve, takes a message for anything it can't handle, and passes off-script calls to the manager path you choose, with a backup. A threatening “utility” call then arrives in the manager's inbox as a written summary with a recording, to be checked against the verified numbers sheet calmly the next morning, not handled by a rattled host in the middle of service (how it works).
Frequently asked questions
Do real health inspectors call ahead to collect fees?
Do not try to judge that from the call. Government impostors threaten license suspensions, fines and lawsuits to get paid fast[3]. Take the caller's details and have a manager call the health department on a number from its website or your last inspection report before anything is paid.
The caller ID showed the utility's real number. Is it genuine?
Not necessarily. Scammers often fake their phone numbers, which is why the FTC advises small businesses not to trust caller ID[3]. Hang up and call the number printed on your last bill.
Can a host safely confirm our listing details with a caller?
Confirming opening hours is harmless; reading out a code, giving account logins or agreeing to pay is not. Google says it never asks businesses for payment to stay on Google[8], so any payment request on a listing call is a reason to end it.
A customer overpaid a catering order and wants the difference sent elsewhere. What should we do?
Refund only to the original payment method, and only after the funds have cleared. The FTC describes overpay-and-refund requests as a classic fake-check scam, and fake checks can take weeks to be discovered[5].
Where do we report a scam call?
Report it to the FTC through its ReportFraud site, note it in your manager log, and tell the agency or company that was impersonated using its official number. Warn your team at the next pre-shift, because scammers often call the same business again.
References
Federal Trade Commission (2025). Consumer Sentinel Network Data Book 2024 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2025). New FTC Data Show a Big Jump in Reported Losses to Fraud to $12.5 Billion in 2024 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2023). Scams and Your Small Business: A Guide for Business (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission, Consumer Advice (2023). Avoiding and Reporting Gift Card Scams (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission, Consumer Advice (2026). How To Spot, Avoid, and Report Fake Check Scams (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute (Cornell Law School), US Code (2026). 47 U.S. Code 227(e): Prohibition on provision of inaccurate caller identification information (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2024). FTC Announces Impersonation Rule Goes into Effect Today (opens in a new tab) ↑
Google Business Profile Help (2026). Calls and messages from Google to businesses (opens in a new tab) ↑