Catering

Missed Catering Calls: The Revenue at Risk

One unanswered catering call can outweigh a night of dinner covers. Estimate what missed catering calls cost from your own close rate and order size.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing9 min read

On this page
  1. One call, many covers
  2. Why catering calls get missed
  3. Why the callback rarely saves it
  4. When the host does pick up
  5. Find the catering calls in your phone log
  6. Put a monthly number on it
  7. The orders behind the first order
  8. Getting the calls answered
  9. Measure again in four weeks
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Catering: Missed Catering Calls: The Revenue at Risk19%: of US adults generally answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers, so most callbacks hit voicemailCATERINGMissed Catering Calls: TheRevenue at Risk19%of US adults generally answer cellphone calls from unknownnumbers, so most callbacks hit voicemailAva for RestaurantsInsightsCatering: Missed Catering Calls: The Revenue at Risk19%: of US adults generally answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers, so most callbacks hit voicemailCATERINGMissed CateringCalls: The Revenue atRisk19%of US adults generally answercellphone calls from unknown numbers,so most callbacks hit voicemailAva for Restaurants
Figure source: Pew Research Center, 2020[1]

Key takeaways

  • Price a missed catering call in dinner covers. In the Example table, a 40-person drop-off buffet is worth about 23 covers at a $38 check.
  • Catering calls arrive when phones are busiest, and the buyer usually has other caterers on the list[2].
  • Calling back rarely rescues them: only 19% of adults generally answer calls from unknown numbers[1].
  • Monthly value at risk = catering calls × 4.33 × missed share × new-order share × close rate × average order, from your own four weeks of data.
  • Count the repeat value too. Missing the first call from an office often means missing the whole account.

One call, many covers

A catering call that rings out at 12:15 is not one lost guest. It is a team lunch, a retirement party or a standing Thursday order, and it is often worth more than every table seated that afternoon. Owners feel a weak dinner rush in the sales report the same night. A missed catering call never shows up at all, because the order was placed somewhere else.

The quickest way to make the loss concrete is to price catering in the unit you already watch: covers. Divide the order value by your average dinner check.

Example figures only. Swap in your own per-head prices and your own average dinner check.
Order (Example)GuestsPer headOrder valueDinner covers at a $38 check
Boxed lunches for a meeting25$16$400About 11
Hot buffet, drop-off40$22$880About 23
Staffed buffet with setup80$38$3,04080
Office lunch every other week, for a year30$18$14,040About 370

Example: if your dining room averages a $38 check, the drop-off buffet in the second row is worth about as much as 23 dinner covers, close to a full turn of a 24-seat section. Miss two of those calls a week and the gap is bigger than most local marketing can make up.

Why catering calls get missed

Catering buyers call during their working day, and their working day overlaps yours. Office managers order lunch from their desks between meetings, often while your line is full and the host is seating a walk-in. Families planning a party call after work, in the middle of the dinner push. The person who can quote is on the floor or in the kitchen, and the person holding the phone cannot answer “what would 40 people cost?” Many of these buyers want a conversation, too: in a Cornell study, about two-thirds of diners who had not booked a table online said they wanted to talk to someone to make a booking[3].

The buyer rarely waits for you. Event planners solicit bids from several venues and service providers as a normal part of the job[2], and office managers run a quicker version of the same thing: three numbers, and the first one that answers properly gets the order. There were 13,929 private caterer establishments in the US in 2025, before counting the restaurants that cater on the side[4]. The next number on the buyer's list is never far away.

Off-premises customers are clear about what they expect. In National Restaurant Association research, 94% of consumers said speed is critical when ordering off-premises, and over 9 in 10 named customer service as a top priority[5]. A catering call that goes to voicemail fails on both counts.

Why the callback rarely saves it

The usual fallback is to call back later, and it works less often than it feels like it should. In Pew Research Center's 2020 survey, only 19% of US adults said they generally answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers; 67% let them ring and check any voicemail, and 14% ignore the voicemail as well[1]. A catering manager returning calls from a personal mobile at 3 pm is an unknown number.

What US adults do when an unknown number callsPew Research Center survey of 10,211 US adults, July 2020.
What US adults do when an unknown number callsStacked bar chart. Generally answer: 19%; Let it ring, check voicemail: 67%; Let it ring, ignore voicemail: 14%.Generally answer: 19% (19%)Let it ring, check voicemail: 67% (67%)Let it ring, ignore voicemail: 14% (14%)What US adults do when an unknown number callsStacked bar chart. Generally answer: 19%; Let it ring, check voicemail: 67%; Let it ring, ignore voicemail: 14%.Generally answer: 19% (19%)Let it ring, check voicemail: 67% (67%)Let it ring, ignore voicemail: 14% (14%)
  • Generally answer 19%
  • Let it ring, check voicemail 67%
  • Let it ring, ignore voicemail 14%

Source: Pew Research Center, 2020[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Generally answer19%
Let it ring, check voicemail67%
Let it ring, ignore voicemail14%

By then the buyer may have moved on. If they called you at 12:15 and two other caterers by 12:30, whoever picked up has probably already sent a menu. Calling back still matters, but treat it as recovery, not as answering, and give it a deadline: how fast to respond to catering leads sets targets by channel.

  • Call back from the restaurant's main number, the one the buyer dialed, so the call is recognized.
  • Leave a voicemail with your name, the restaurant, a direct line, and a promise to quote today.
  • If the caller left an email address, reply there as well, with the same details.
  • Log the outcome every time: reached, voicemail, wrong number, or already booked elsewhere.

When the host does pick up

Some catering calls are answered and still lost. The host picks up mid-rush, says the catering manager is out, takes a first name and promises a callback that turns into phone tag. That call counts as answered in the phone log and as missed in practice. A 40-second script fixes most of it.

Script: “Thanks for calling about catering. I can't quote it right now, but I'll take the details so our catering manager can call you with prices by [time]. What's the date, and roughly how many people? Drop-off or staffed? Where is it? Any allergies we should plan around? And the best number, and is it okay to email you too?”

  • Keep the five fields on a card at the host stand, in the same order as the script, with a line for the callback time promised.
  • Promise a specific time, not “later today”. A buyer who hears 3 pm can wait; one who hears “soon” keeps dialing.
  • Put the card in one place the catering manager checks after lunch, not in a pocket or under the reservation book.
  • Count these calls separately in the log, so you can see whether host-taken leads close as well as the ones the manager takes directly.

The script works only when the host has a free minute, which during a full lunch service is often not the case. That is the gap the forwarding options further down are meant to close.

Find the catering calls in your phone log

Most business phone systems can export inbound calls with the time, the length and whether anyone answered. Catering calls are not labelled, but they leave tracks you can follow.

  1. Pull four weeks of calls

    Export every inbound call with time, duration and answer status. Four weeks smooths out one unusual week.

  2. Mark the catering windows

    Flag missed calls on weekdays from late morning to early afternoon, and in the early evening, when office and party buyers tend to call.

  3. Listen to the voicemails

    Count the messages that mention lunch for a group, a party, an event, trays or a quote. These are confirmed catering calls.

  4. Check the numbers

    Business numbers, and repeat callers who never order takeout, are likely catering. A quick search of a number often shows whose office it is.

  5. Ask the buyers who did reach you

    For two weeks, ask every new catering buyer whether they tried calling first. Each “yes, nobody picked up” is a measured miss.

The full method for every call type is in how to measure missed calls at your restaurant. For catering you need only two numbers from it: catering calls per week, and the share that nobody answered.

Put a monthly number on it

With four weeks of data, five inputs give a monthly figure. Use your own. The example below is a mid-size restaurant with a growing drop-off catering business.

ExampleExample: monthly catering revenue at risk from unanswered calls
Example: worked figures
InputExample
Catering calls a week12
Share nobody answered (%)30%
Share that were new orders (%)70%
Answered inquiries that book (%)35%
Average catering order$850
Unanswered calls a month16
From new customers11
Bookings that would have followed3.8
Monthly value at risk$3,246

How it is worked out: Calls a week × 4.33 weeks × unanswered share × new-customer share × booking rate × average value.

Assumptions

  • Phone remains a main way people book with restaurants: 49% of reservations at top US restaurants came by telephone in Cornell's 2012 study.[6]
  • Callbacks recover few of these calls, because only 19% of adults generally answer calls from unknown numbers.[1]
  • The new-order share and close rate come from the restaurant's own inquiry log; changes to booked orders are left out.

Example. Monthly value at risk = calls a week × 4.33 × missed share × new-order share × close rate × average order. It counts first orders only.

In this example the result is about $3,250 a month, close to $39,000 a year, in first orders alone. Two cautions keep it honest. First, the close rate should be your rate on answered catering inquiries, not a guess; if you do not track it yet, catering close rate tracking shows how to start. Second, some missed callers leave a voicemail and still book after a fast callback. If your log shows that, lower the missed share to the calls that were never recovered.

Example: where one month of catering calls goes
  1. 52

    catering calls in the month

  2. 16

    rang out or went to voicemail

  3. 11

    were new orders rather than changes

  4. 3.8

    would have booked at a 35% close rate

  5. $3,250

    in first orders at $850 each, rounded

Example figures from the calculator above, rounded at each step.

Example: the inputs move the result in a straight line, which makes the levers easy to compare. Cutting the missed share from 30% to 15% halves the figure to about $1,620 a month. Raising the close rate on answered calls from 35% to 45% lifts the value of every answered call by the same proportion, but does nothing for the calls that rang out. Answering comes first; selling better comes second.

The orders behind the first order

The calculator counts one order per caller, and for office catering that undercounts. An office that finds a caterer it trusts tends to keep ordering: the team lunch, the quarterly all-hands, the holiday party. Example: an office that orders lunch for 30 every other week at $18 a head is worth about $14,000 a year. Miss its first call and the whole account goes to whoever answered.

That is why the call most worth protecting is the first one from a business you have never served. Winning office catering accounts and keeping repeat catering clients cover what happens after the first order. None of it starts if the phone rang out.

Getting the calls answered

There is no single fix. The right one depends on when your catering calls arrive and who is free to take them.

  • Give catering its own number or menu option, printed on the catering page and on invoices, so those calls can ring somewhere other than the host stand. Separate lines for takeout, catering and reservations weighs the trade-offs.
  • Forward calls nobody picks up after a set number of rings to a manager's line, an answering service or an SI Employee. Call forwarding for restaurants covers the settings.
  • Give hosts a catering card with the five intake fields and a callback window to promise, so a call they do answer is not wasted.
  • Block out a callback hour after lunch service and keep it, so callers can be told a real time.

Forwarding to an SI Employee changes what an unanswered catering call turns into. The restaurant forwards its number on overflow or after hours, the call is answered in the restaurant's name, and the event date, guest count, service style and callback details go to the catering manager as an emailed summary, with the transcript in the AssistCall inbox. Menus and prices stay with your team, so the manager still writes the quote, but from a complete lead instead of a missed-call entry. What it does lists what it handles today.

Calls after closing deserve their own look. An OpenTable estimate cited in Cornell research put 25% of online reservations between 10 pm and 10 am[7], and people planning parties keep similar hours. After-hours catering and event inquiries covers that window.

Measure again in four weeks

Change one thing, then rerun the same four-week log. Compare catering calls answered, complete leads captured, and catering orders booked from phone inquiries. If the answered share rises and orders do not, the problem has moved downstream to quoting and follow-up, which is a better problem to have.

For missed calls across reservations and takeout as well, see what a missed call costs a restaurant. The restaurant group catering example models how one group would route these calls across three locations and what its events manager would get from each one.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know which missed calls were catering?

Listen to the voicemails, check whether the numbers belong to businesses, and ask new catering buyers whether they tried calling first. Four weeks of that gives a count you can use.

What close rate should I use in the calculator?

Your own: booked catering orders divided by catering inquiries that reached someone, over the last two or three months. Results vary too much by menu, price and market for an outside figure to stand in for yours.

Is a fast callback enough to recover missed catering calls?

Sometimes. But only 19% of adults generally answer calls from unknown numbers[1], and buyers often call several caterers. Call back from the restaurant's number, leave a clear voicemail, and treat callbacks as recovery rather than the plan.

Why are catering calls worth more than reservation calls?

One catering order feeds many guests. In the Example table, a 40-person drop-off buffet is worth about 23 dinner covers, and an office that orders every other week is worth hundreds of covers over a year.

Should catering have its own phone number?

It helps when that number rings somewhere other than the host stand and is published consistently. A separate number with nobody behind it during lunch service only moves the missed calls.

References

  1. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Meeting, Convention, and Event Planners (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Cornell University Center for Hospitality Research (Kimes and Kies) (2012). The Role of Multi-Restaurant Reservation Sites in Restaurant Distribution Management (Cornell Hospitality Report, 2012) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages, 2025 annual averages, NAICS 722320 (US private) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. National Restaurant Association (2025). From Trend to Transformation: Off-Premises Dining Now Essential for Restaurant Consumers, Operators (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Cornell University Center for Hospitality Research (Kimes and Kies) (2012). The Role of Multi-Restaurant Reservation Sites in Restaurant Distribution Management (Cornell Hospitality Report, 2012) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Cornell University Center for Hospitality Research (Sheryl E. Kimes) (2009). How Restaurant Customers View Online Reservations (Cornell Hospitality Report Vol. 9, No. 5) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo