Marketing and Local Growth

Menu Design and Menu Psychology That Sells

Use menu engineering, layout, descriptions and price formatting to steer guests to the dishes you want to sell, plus US rules on calories and fees.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why the menu matters more when costs rise
  2. Menu engineering before menu design
  3. Example: engineering a starters section
  4. Layout: guide the eye, do not trap it
  5. Price formatting that keeps attention on the food
  6. Descriptions that sell
  7. Drinks, sides and add-ons
  8. Test, measure and repeat
  9. The rules every US menu must follow
  10. Keep online menus in step
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Marketing and Local Growth: Menu Design and Menu Psychology That SellsArticle coverMARKETING AND LOCAL GROWTHMenu Design and MenuPsychology That SellsAva for RestaurantsInsightsMarketing and Local Growth: Menu Design and Menu Psychology That SellsArticle coverMARKETING AND LOCAL GROWTHMenu Design and MenuPsychology That SellsAva for Restaurants

Key takeaways

  • Start with menu engineering: sort every dish by popularity and contribution margin before touching the design.
  • Feature the high-margin dishes guests already like; fix, reprice or remove the rest.
  • Format prices quietly and write short, specific descriptions; the dish should sell, not the number.
  • Chains with 20 or more locations must post calories, and some states require any mandatory fees to be shown with prices.

Why the menu matters more when costs rise

The menu is the one sales tool every guest reads. When costs move fast, it is also the main lever on margin. USDA forecasts beef and veal prices to rise 8.7% in 2026, while restaurant menu prices are forecast to rise 3.5% and grocery prices 2.3%[1]. Guests notice the gap: in the 12 months to September 2026, grocery prices rose 1.8%, about half the pace of restaurant menu prices[2], and full-service meal prices rose 3.8%[3].

USDA food price forecastsForecast annual price change, USDA Economic Research Service Food Price Outlook.
USDA food price forecastsBar chart. Beef and veal, 2026: 8.7%; Restaurant (food away from home), 2026: 3.5%; Restaurant (food away from home), 2027: 2.8%; Grocery (food at home), 2026: 2.3%.Beef and veal, 2026Beef and veal, 2026: 8.7%8.7%Restaurant (food away from home), 2026Restaurant (food away from home), 2026: 3.5%3.5%Restaurant (food away from home), 2027Restaurant (food away from home), 2027: 2.8%2.8%Grocery (food at home), 2026Grocery (food at home), 2026: 2.3%2.3%USDA food price forecastsBar chart. Beef and veal, 2026: 8.7%; Restaurant (food away from home), 2026: 3.5%; Restaurant (food away from home), 2027: 2.8%; Grocery (food at home), 2026: 2.3%.Beef and veal, 2026Beef and veal, 2026: 8.7%8.7%Restaurant (food away from home), 2026Restaurant (food away from home), 2026: 3.5%3.5%Restaurant (food away from home), 2027Restaurant (food away from home), 2027: 2.8%2.8%Grocery (food at home), 2026Grocery (food at home), 2026: 2.3%2.3%

Source: USDA Economic Research Service, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Beef and veal, 20268.7%
Restaurant (food away from home), 20263.5%
Restaurant (food away from home), 20272.8%
Grocery (food at home), 20262.3%

Raising every price by the same amount is the bluntest response. A well-designed menu does better: it steers guests toward dishes that earn more, keeps value visible on the items guests compare, and drops dishes that cost more than they earn.

Menu engineering sorts every dish into four groups using two numbers: how many you sell and how much each one contributes after food cost. The names come from a long-standing hospitality framework and are widely used in kitchens.

The four menu engineering groups and how to treat each.
GroupPopularityMarginWhat to do
StarsHighHighFeature them, keep the recipe and portion stable, protect the price
PlowhorsesHighLowRe-cost the recipe, adjust portion or garnish, consider a small price rise
PuzzlesLowHighMove to a better spot, rewrite the description, have servers recommend it
DogsLowLowRemove, or keep only if it serves a real purpose, such as a children's item
  1. Pull three months of sales

    Export unit sales by item from the POS for a normal period, leaving out holidays and special events.

  2. Cost every recipe

    Calculate the current plate cost of each dish using recent invoices, including garnishes, sides and sauces.

  3. Work out contribution

    Contribution is menu price minus plate cost. Find the average contribution and average popularity for each menu section.

  4. Sort into the four groups

    Above average on both is a star, popular but below average contribution is a plowhorse, and so on.

  5. Decide one action per dish

    Feature, re-cost, reposition, reprice or remove. Write the decision next to each item before redesigning anything.

Example: engineering a starters section

Example (fictional): a bistro's starters section has five dishes. Over three months, the fried calamari sells 900 portions at a contribution of $9 each, the burrata 300 portions at $11, the soup 850 portions at $5, the crab cakes 250 portions at $6 and a beet salad 150 portions at $7.

Example: calamari is a star; burrata is a puzzle with a strong margin but few sales; soup is a plowhorse; crab cakes and beet salad are dogs. The owner moves burrata to the top of the section with a short new description, re-costs the soup by switching to a seasonal vegetable base, removes the crab cakes, and keeps the beet salad as the only vegetarian starter but changes its garnish to cut cost.

Layout: guide the eye, do not trap it

Popular advice about exactly where guests look first is not well settled, so treat layout rules as hypotheses and test them against your own sales. A few principles hold up in practice.

  • Keep sections short. Guests decide faster and feel more confident when each section offers a manageable choice.
  • Put the dish you most want to sell first or last in its section, and give it a little more space or a short story.
  • Use a box, a line or a small icon to highlight one or two dishes per page, not every dish.
  • Group items the way guests think: starters, mains, sides, desserts, drinks, with shareable plates together.
  • Leave white space. A crowded menu reads as cheap and makes every dish compete with every other.
  • Make the type readable in your actual lighting, and test the menu at the table at night before printing.

Price formatting that keeps attention on the food

Many designers keep prices quiet so the guest reads the dish before the number. Common practices include leaving off currency signs and trailing zeros, placing the price at the end of the description rather than in a right-hand column, and avoiding dotted leader lines that pull the eye across the page to the number. None of these hides the price; they simply stop the menu from reading like a price list.

  • Write the price as a plain number in the same font size as the description, without a currency sign or cents.
  • Place prices directly after the description, not lined up in a column guests can scan for the cheapest dish.
  • Avoid ending prices in .99, which feels like a discount store in most full-service rooms.
  • Use an anchor: a premium dish at the top of a section makes the dishes below it feel reasonable.
  • For shareable and family-style plates, show the price per dish, not per person, unless the menu is a set price.

Descriptions that sell

Good descriptions are short and specific. They name the main ingredient, the method and one detail that makes the dish yours: where something comes from, how long it is cooked, a family origin. Avoid stacks of adjectives such as delicious, mouthwatering and perfect, which guests skip.

  • Weak: Delicious grilled chicken with amazing sauce and fresh vegetables.
  • Better: Half chicken, brined overnight and grilled over oak, with salsa verde and charred broccolini.
  • Weak: Our famous chocolate cake.
  • Better: Grandma Ruth's chocolate cake, three layers, salted caramel, served warm.

Drinks, sides and add-ons

Some of the highest margins on the menu sit outside the mains. Drinks, sides, sauces, extra proteins and desserts are often where a check grows, and they need the same design attention. Suggest a pairing in the description of a main, such as a wine or a side, so the add-on feels like part of the dish rather than an upsell.

  • List two or three house cocktails or non-alcoholic drinks with short descriptions near the top of the drinks menu.
  • Offer add-ons in a single line under each relevant section, such as add grilled shrimp or add an egg.
  • Give desserts their own card or a clear section so they are not an afterthought at the bottom of the page.
  • Train servers to mention one pairing per table, based on what the guest has ordered.

Test, measure and repeat

Treat every menu change as a test. Before you print, write down what you expect to happen: more burrata sold, fewer soup portions, a higher share of tables ordering dessert. Run the new menu for at least four weeks, then compare unit sales and contribution with the same weeks before the change.

Change a few things at a time so you can tell what worked. If a repositioned puzzle dish still does not sell after a month, ask servers what guests say about it; sometimes the problem is the name, the price or the dish itself, not its place on the page. Keep a simple log of each menu version, the date and the results, so the next redesign starts from evidence instead of opinion.

The rules every US menu must follow

FDA menu labeling requirements apply to restaurants and similar retail food establishments that are part of a chain with 20 or more locations[4]. Covered chains must post calories for standard menu items and display a statement that 2,000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice, plus a statement that written nutrition information is available on request[4]. Smaller independents are not covered unless they opt in or their state or city has its own rules.

Allergens come up at every table. Sesame became the ninth major food allergen in the US under the FASTER Act, with FDA requirements applying from January 1, 2023[5]. Packaged-food labeling rules do not apply to dishes cooked to order, but many restaurants add a line asking guests to tell their server about allergies, and some state and local codes require such a notice.

Fees belong on the menu too. Under California's hidden-fees law, restaurant and bar mandatory fees are exempt only if the fee is clearly and conspicuously displayed wherever prices are shown[6]. If you add a service charge or a kitchen appreciation fee, check your state's rules and show it plainly.

Keep online menus in step

Most guests see your menu on a phone before they see it on paper. Use the same dish names, order and descriptions on your website, ordering page and delivery apps as on the printed menu, and update all of them on the same day. Reorder online sections so stars appear first, and remove dogs everywhere at once. For photos that support the layout, see restaurant food photography; for launching changes, see seasonal menu launch marketing.

Frequently asked questions

What is menu engineering?

A method that sorts each dish by popularity and contribution margin into stars, plowhorses, puzzles and dogs, so you know which to feature, re-cost, reposition or remove.

Should restaurant menus show dollar signs?

Many designers leave them off and drop trailing zeros so the dish is read before the price. It is a style choice; prices must still be clear and accurate.

Do independent restaurants have to post calories?

Federal menu labeling applies to chains with 20 or more locations. Independents are not covered unless they opt in or a state or local rule applies.

How often should I redesign my menu?

Re-engineer it at least twice a year, or whenever costs move sharply. A full redesign is needed less often if the layout already works.

References

  1. USDA Economic Research Service (2026). Food Price Outlook - Summary Findings (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Consumer Price Index: series CUUR0000SAF11 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Consumer Price Index: series CUUR0000SEFV01 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. US Food and Drug Administration (2026). Menu Labeling Requirements (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. US Food and Drug Administration (2023). Food Allergies (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. California Department of Justice, Office of the Attorney General (2024). SB 478 - Hidden Fees (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo