Key takeaways
- Employers must complete Section 2 of Form I-9 within 3 business days of an employee's first day of paid work, or on the first day if the job lasts less than 3 days[1].
- Employees choose which acceptable documents to present; you cannot ask for specific ones[1].
- E-Verify cases must be created no later than the third business day after the employee starts work for pay, and only after the I-9 is complete[2].
- Keep each I-9 for 3 years after hire or 1 year after employment ends, whichever is later, and be able to produce it within 3 business days of an inspection request[3].
Why I-9s are a bigger job in restaurants
Every new employee needs a Form I-9, and restaurants hire more often than almost any other business. The hires rate in accommodation and food services was 6.1% in September 2026, meaning about 6 in 100 employees were new that month[4], and the quits rate was 5.0%[5]. A 40-person restaurant can complete dozens of I-9s a year and hold hundreds of forms for former employees. Small errors repeated across that volume are what inspections find.
The fix is a routine that does not depend on who is managing that day: a fixed onboarding checklist, a calendar for retention, and a periodic self-audit.
Assign one trained person per location to own I-9s, usually the general manager or an office manager, with a named backup. Shift managers who rarely complete the form are the most likely to miss a field, accept the wrong documents or forget the three-day deadline during a busy week. Centralizing the task costs a few minutes per hire and removes most of the risk.
The I-9 timeline for each new hire
After the offer is accepted
Give the employee the form and the list of acceptable documents. Do not complete the I-9 or ask for documents before a job offer.
By the first day of paid work
The employee completes Section 1 with their information and attestation.
Within 3 business days
You complete Section 2 after examining the documents the employee chooses to present; the hire date is the first day of paid work[1].
If the job lasts less than 3 days
Complete Section 2 no later than the first day of work for pay[1]. This catches one-off banquet and event staff.
If you use E-Verify
Create the case using the I-9 information no later than the third business day after the employee starts work for pay[2].
File the form
Store it in the I-9 file, separate from the personnel file, and add the purge date to your retention calendar.
Documents: let the employee choose
USCIS is clear that employees may choose to present either one document from List A, or a combination of one document from List B and one from List C, and that if an employee presents an acceptable List A document, you should not ask for List B or C documents[1]. Asking for a specific document, such as a green card or a passport, or rejecting valid documents that reasonably appear genuine, can be treated as discrimination.
- Examine original documents, not photocopies, unless you use an authorized alternative procedure.
- Check that the documents reasonably appear genuine and relate to the person in front of you.
- Record document titles, numbers and expiry dates in Section 2.
- Treat every new hire the same way, whatever their accent, appearance or stated citizenship.
- Never ask applicants about work authorization documents before making a job offer.
Remote examination for E-Verify employers
Employers must generally examine documents in person, but employers that participate in E-Verify may use an alternative procedure authorized by the Department of Homeland Security, and must check the box in Section 2 indicating they used it[1]. For a multi-unit group that hires centrally, that can simplify onboarding. If you use it, apply it consistently: you cannot use the remote procedure for some employees at a location and require in-person examination for others on a discriminatory basis.
E-Verify basics
E-Verify compares information from the I-9 with government records. Federally it is voluntary for most private employers, but some states require it for some or all employers, and federal contractors can be required to use it. Check your state's rules before deciding.
- Complete Form I-9 before creating a case in E-Verify[2].
- Create the case no later than the third business day after the employee starts work for pay[2].
- Do not use E-Verify to screen applicants before an offer, or to re-check existing employees selectively.
- If a case returns a mismatch, give the employee the notice and the chance to resolve it, and do not take adverse action while it is pending.
- Post the required E-Verify and right-to-work notices where applicants and employees can see them.
Rehires, seasonal staff and expiring documents
Restaurants rehire often: students who come back every summer, servers who leave and return, banquet staff called in a few times a year. Decide how you handle each case and write it into your onboarding checklist.
- Seasonal staff who stay on payroll between seasons, with no break in employment, generally do not need a new I-9 each season. Confirm how your payroll system records the break.
- Rehires within the retention period may in some cases be handled using the original form's supplement rather than a new form; check current USCIS guidance before relying on it, and complete a new form if in doubt.
- Banquet and event staff who work occasional single shifts still need an I-9 on or before their first paid day, even if they will only work once.
- Some work authorization documents expire. Track expiry dates from Section 2 and follow USCIS rules for reverification; do not reverify identity documents or U.S. citizens' documents.
Retention: how long to keep each form
Keep each employee's Form I-9 for three years after the date of hire, or one year after the date employment ends, whichever is later[3]. For short-tenure restaurant staff, the three-year rule usually decides. For long-serving staff, the one-year-after-termination rule does.
Source: US Citizenship and Immigration Services, 2026[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Leaves after 6 months | 3 years |
| Leaves after 2 years | 3 years |
| Leaves after 5 years | 6 years |
| Leaves after 10 years | 11 years |
Example: a fictional line cook hired on March 1, 2026 who leaves on September 1, 2026 has a purge date of March 1, 2029, three years after hire. A server hired on March 1, 2020 who leaves on March 1, 2026 has a purge date of March 1, 2027, one year after leaving, because that is later than three years after hire.
Forms may be kept on paper, microfilm or microfiche, or electronically[3]. Wherever they are stored, you must be able to present them within three business days of an inspection request[3].
Run a self-audit once a year
- Compare your payroll list of current employees with your I-9 files; every current employee needs a form.
- Check that former employees' forms are kept until the purge date and destroyed after it.
- Review Section 1 and Section 2 for blanks, missing signatures and late dates.
- Check that Section 2 dates fall within three business days of the hire date.
- Look for patterns of requesting specific documents, which can signal discrimination.
- Correct errors properly: strike through, write the correct information, initial and date; never backdate or re-create a form.
- Keep a short memo describing the audit and what you corrected.
If a notice of inspection arrives
Note the deadline
Record the date received and the production deadline, and tell the owner the same day.
Call counsel
Speak to an employment or immigration lawyer before producing anything.
Gather the forms
Pull I-9s for current employees and for former employees still within retention, plus any payroll list the notice requests.
Do not alter forms
Do not backdate, re-create or correct forms after the notice without legal advice.
Keep a copy of everything produced
Log what was provided and when, and keep copies.
Common restaurant I-9 mistakes
- Letting new hires work a week of shifts before anyone completes Section 2.
- Skipping the I-9 for short-term banquet or event staff.
- Keeping photocopies of documents for some employees and not others.
- Storing I-9s in personnel files that many managers can open.
- Completing a new I-9 for a rehire without checking whether the original can be used.
- Holding forms forever, or shredding them too early, because nobody tracks purge dates.
Inspection readiness rule of thumb: if a notice arrived today, could you hand over every current employee's I-9, and every former employee's still within retention, within three business days? If not, fix storage first.
Frequently asked questions
When does a restaurant have to complete Form I-9?
The employee completes Section 1 by the first day of paid work, and the employer completes Section 2 within 3 business days of that date, or on the first day if the job lasts less than 3 days.
Can I ask a new hire for a specific ID?
No. Employees choose which acceptable documents to present, either one from List A or one each from Lists B and C.
Is E-Verify required for restaurants?
It is voluntary for most private employers under federal law, but some states require it. If you use it, create cases no later than the third business day after the employee starts work for pay.
How long do I keep I-9s for former employees?
Three years after the date of hire or one year after employment ends, whichever is later.
References
US Citizenship and Immigration Services, I-9 Central (2026). Completing Section 2, Employer Review and Attestation (opens in a new tab) ↑
E-Verify (US Department of Homeland Security) (2026). E-Verify User Manual: 2.2 Create a Case (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Citizenship and Immigration Services (2026). Handbook for Employers M-274: 10.0 Retaining Form I-9 (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey: series JTS720000000000000HIR (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey: series JTS720000000000000QUR (opens in a new tab) ↑