Key takeaways
- Ask every table about allergies at the order, not only when a guest volunteers it, and confirm the answer back.
- Route every allergy order the same way: flagged ticket, verbal call to the kitchen, check at the pass, and delivery by someone who knows it is an allergy plate.
- Never promise 'allergen-free'. Say what the kitchen will do and what risk remains, then let the guest decide.
- Training is the gap: in a CDC study, fewer than half of restaurant managers and a third of servers had received food allergy training[1].
Why table-side allergy handling needs a routine
Allergy requests are routine in every dining room, yet they are handled with surprisingly little system. When FALCPA passed, the eight major allergens it named accounted for 90 percent of US food allergies and serious allergic reactions[2]. Sesame became the ninth major allergen under the FASTER Act, with FDA requirements applying from January 1, 2023[3]. Today the nine are milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, soybeans and sesame.
A CDC study of restaurants at six sites found clear gaps. Only 44.4 percent of managers, 40.8 percent of food workers and 33.3 percent of servers said they had received food allergy training[1]. Just 19.1 percent of managers reported dedicated equipment or utensils for allergen-free food, and 7.6 percent reported a special kitchen area for it[1]. The people taking the order are the least trained, which is exactly where a routine helps most.
The server script
The script has three jobs: find out about allergies early, get the details right, and set honest expectations. Servers can use their own words, but each element below should be there.
- Ask early, every table: 'Before I tell you about tonight's dishes, does anyone at the table have a food allergy I should know about?' Asking every table normalizes it and catches guests who would not volunteer it.
- Get specifics: 'Which foods, and is it an allergy or a preference? How careful do we need to be with traces or shared equipment?' The answer decides how the kitchen handles the order.
- Do not guess: 'Let me check that dish with the chef rather than guess.' Servers should never answer from memory about ingredients, sauces or frying oil.
- Be honest about limits: 'We can make that without peanuts and use clean equipment, but our kitchen does handle peanuts, so I can't promise there is no trace.' Then let the guest choose.
- Confirm back: 'So that's one salmon, no dairy at all, including butter in the sauce. I'll flag it with the kitchen and bring it out myself.'
Never say 'allergen-free', 'totally safe' or 'there's nothing in it'. You cannot see every ingredient label, every supplier change or every cross-contact risk on a busy line. Describe what you will do, not a guarantee.
The ticket routine from order to table
Enter the allergy in the POS
Use a dedicated allergy modifier that prints in a different color or format, not a free-text note buried under other modifiers. Name the allergen.
Tell the kitchen in person
The server or a manager walks to the pass and tells the expeditor or chef: 'Table 12, seat 3, severe tree nut allergy on the risotto.' Printed tickets get missed; a spoken call adds a second check.
Check the recipe and labels
The chef confirms the dish's ingredients, including stocks, sauces, garnishes and any bought-in components, against the recipe card and current product labels.
Prepare with clean equipment
Wash hands, change gloves, and use clean boards, pans and utensils. Do not use shared fryer oil for a guest avoiding an allergen that has been fried in it.
Mark the plate
Use an allergy pick or plate marker and keep the dish separate at the pass.
Deliver directly
The server or a manager carries the plate to the guest, not a runner who does not know about the allergy, and confirms: 'This is your dairy-free salmon.'
Check back
Return soon after to check everything is fine, and watch for any sign of a reaction.
Where allergens hide
| Allergen | Common hidden sources | Question for the kitchen |
|---|---|---|
| Milk | Butter finishing sauces, bread wash, whey in spice blends | Is butter or cream added at the end? |
| Eggs | Pasta, egg wash on pastry, aioli, some batters | Is the pasta or batter made with egg? |
| Wheat | Thickened sauces, soy sauce, croutons, dusting flour | Is anything floured or thickened? |
| Soy | Soy sauce, vegetable oil blends, marinades, bread | Which oil and marinade does this use? |
| Peanuts and tree nuts | Pesto, romesco, mole, praline, nut oils, garnishes | Any nuts or nut oil in the sauce or garnish? |
| Sesame | Tahini, hummus, dressings, sesame oil, seeded buns | Is the bun or dressing seeded or made with sesame oil? |
| Fish and shellfish | Caesar dressing, fish sauce, stock, Worcestershire sauce, shared fryer oil | Any fish sauce or shellfish stock, and is the fryer shared? |
Ingredient information is the foundation. In the CDC study, only 55.2 percent of managers said their restaurant had ingredient lists or recipes for all or most menu items[1]. Without them, every allergy order depends on someone's memory.
Allergy, intolerance or preference: why the difference matters
Guests use the word allergy for many things: a life-threatening peanut allergy, a lactose intolerance, celiac disease, a dislike of cilantro. Staff should treat every stated allergy seriously, but asking one clarifying question lets the kitchen respond in proportion.
- Severe allergy: the guest needs no trace of the allergen. Use the full routine above, including clean equipment and direct delivery, and be clear about any cross-contact risk you cannot remove.
- Celiac disease or strict gluten avoidance: treat like a severe allergy for cross-contact, including shared fryers, pasta water and toasters.
- Intolerance: the guest wants the ingredient left out but may tolerate small amounts. Ask; do not assume.
- Preference or diet: leave the ingredient out as requested, without the full allergy routine, and do not label the order as an allergy.
- Unsure: if the guest is not sure, use the full routine. The cost of over-caution is a few minutes.
Never challenge a guest about whether an allergy is real. A server who sounds skeptical teaches guests to stop mentioning allergies, which is the most dangerous outcome of all.
If a guest has a reaction
- Get the manager immediately and call 911 if the guest shows signs of a serious reaction, such as trouble breathing, swelling of the face or throat, or collapse.
- Ask whether the guest carries epinephrine and help them reach it. Follow the guest's and dispatcher's lead; do not give food or drink.
- Keep the dish and note what was served, who prepared it and what went wrong.
- Do not discuss fault with the guest or their party in the moment. Focus on their care.
- Write an incident report the same night and review the routine with the kitchen and front-of-house team.
- Contact your insurer according to your policy, and follow any local health department reporting rules.
Rules, codes and what your jurisdiction expects
Restaurant food safety rules are set at state and local level, usually by adopting a version of the FDA Food Code. FDA issued the 2026 edition of the Food Code, the model that state, local, tribal and territorial agencies adopt[4]. The Food Code includes allergen knowledge expectations for the person in charge, and some states and cities go further, with required allergen training, posters or menu notices. Check which version and which extra rules your health department applies.
Federal allergen labeling rules apply to packaged foods, not to dishes made in your kitchen. That gives restaurants more flexibility, but also means guests depend entirely on your staff for accurate information.
Example: the pesto that was not on the ticket
Example (fictional): a guest tells a server she has a tree nut allergy and orders grilled chicken. The server types 'no nuts' in the notes field. The kitchen has recently switched the chicken's garnish to a pistachio pesto, which the server did not know. The free-text note prints at the bottom of the ticket below three other modifiers, and the line cook misses it. The expeditor catches the pesto at the pass only because she happens to read the full ticket.
The manager changes three things the next day: an allergy modifier that prints in red at the top of the ticket, a rule that every allergy order is called verbally to the pass, and a menu-change briefing at pre-shift whenever a garnish, sauce or supplier changes. None of the changes cost much. All of them remove a dependency on luck.
Training checklist
- Every front-of-house hire learns the nine major allergens and the server script before taking a section.
- Every cook learns the clean-equipment routine and where allergens hide in your recipes.
- Recipe cards list allergens for every dish and every sub-recipe, and are updated when suppliers change.
- A current allergen matrix is kept at the pass and at the host stand.
- Managers run a short allergy scenario at pre-shift once a month.
- Allergy incidents and near misses are logged and reviewed.
Allergy questions often arrive before the guest does, by phone or with the booking. Whoever answers should pass them to a manager or chef rather than answer from memory; Ava, for example, hands allergy questions to the manager path you choose instead of answering them. The table-side routine above still applies when the guest sits down. For guests with other access needs, see serving guests who are deaf, blind or use wheelchairs.
Frequently asked questions
What are the nine major food allergens in the US?
Milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, soybeans and sesame. Sesame was added under the FASTER Act, with FDA requirements applying from January 1, 2023.
Can a restaurant guarantee a dish is allergen-free?
No restaurant kitchen that handles an allergen can rule out cross-contact completely. Staff should explain what the kitchen will do, such as clean equipment and checked ingredients, and what risk remains, and let the guest decide.
How should servers flag allergy orders to the kitchen?
Use a dedicated allergy modifier that prints prominently, tell the kitchen in person, and have someone who knows about the allergy deliver the plate and confirm it with the guest.
What should staff do if a guest has an allergic reaction?
Get a manager, call 911 for any sign of a serious reaction, help the guest reach their epinephrine if they carry it, keep the dish, and write up the incident the same night.
References
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2017). Restaurant Food Allergy Practices: Six Selected Sites, United States, 2014 (MMWR 66(15)) (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Food and Drug Administration (2004). Food Allergies (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Food and Drug Administration (2023). Food Allergies (opens in a new tab) ↑
US Food and Drug Administration (2026). FDA Food Code (opens in a new tab) ↑