Staffing, Hiring and Training

Are Unpaid Trial Shifts Legal for Restaurants?

Why restaurant trial shifts and kitchen stages generally have to be paid under the FLSA, what you must pay, and how to run a short paid working interview.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Why trial work counts as work
  3. What about calling it training?
  4. How much you have to pay
  5. Run a paid working interview properly
  6. What it costs, and what it saves
  7. Edge cases to think about
  8. If you have run unpaid trials before
  9. A checklist for owners
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Staffing, Hiring and Training: Are Unpaid Trial Shifts Legal for Restaurants?Article coverSTAFFING, HIRING AND TRAININGAre Unpaid Trial ShiftsLegal for Restaurants?Ava for RestaurantsInsightsStaffing, Hiring and Training: Are Unpaid Trial Shifts Legal for Restaurants?Article coverSTAFFING, HIRING AND TRAININGAre Unpaid TrialShifts Legal forRestaurants?Ava for Restaurants

Key takeaways

  • Under federal law, work you suffer or permit is work time that must be paid; a trial shift on a real station is work[1].
  • Pay at least the applicable minimum wage for every hour, and remember many states and cities set rates above the $7.25 federal floor[2].
  • Tips a candidate earns during a trial belong to the candidate[3].
  • Keep the interview conversation unpaid if you like, but pay for the part where the person works.

The short answer

In most cases, no. If a candidate does productive work for your restaurant, such as prepping, cooking, serving or bussing during a trial shift, federal law generally treats that time as work time that must be paid at least the minimum wage. State and local laws may require more. This is general information, not legal advice; check your state's rules or ask an employment lawyer.

Unpaid stages and 'trail' shifts have a long history in restaurant kitchens, which is why many owners assume they are fine. The law has not followed the custom. A paid working interview costs little, keeps you compliant and tends to attract more serious candidates.

Why trial work counts as work

The Fair Labor Standards Act requires employers to pay for hours worked. The Department of Labor explains that work not requested but suffered or permitted to be performed is work time that must be paid for by the employer[1]. The regulation puts it simply: work not requested but suffered or permitted is work time, and the reason is immaterial[4].

What matters is whether the business knows or has reason to believe the person is working. In a trial shift you have asked them to work, you are watching them do it and you benefit from it. Calling it an audition, a stage or 'just seeing how they fit' does not change the analysis.

  • A cook preps vegetables you will use in tonight's service: work.
  • A candidate runs food to tables or takes orders: work.
  • A candidate cleans down a station or washes dishes: work.
  • A candidate sits with you for a 20-minute interview and a tour: generally not work.
  • A candidate watches service from the pass for a few minutes without doing anything: generally not work, but keep it brief.

What about calling it training?

Some owners argue that a trial is training, and training is sometimes unpaid. The Department of Labor says time spent in lectures, meetings and training programs need not be counted as working time only if four criteria are all met: it is outside normal hours, it is voluntary, it is not job related, and no other work is done at the same time[1].

A trial shift fails at least two of those tests: it is directly related to the job, and the person does productive work. Unpaid internships at for-profit businesses are judged under a separate test that looks at who mainly benefits; a candidate covering a real station during service is unlikely to pass it. Volunteers generally cannot work for a for-profit business.

How much you have to pay

Pay at least the highest minimum wage that applies: federal, state or local. The federal minimum wage is $7.25 an hour[2], but many states and cities set higher rates, and some industries have their own. In California, for example, covered fast food restaurant employees must be paid at least $20.00 an hour[5].

For tipped roles such as servers and bartenders, federal law allows a cash wage of $2.13 an hour with a tip credit of up to $5.12 toward the $7.25 minimum[6]. Using the tip credit has notice and other requirements, and a candidate who earns little in tips during a short trial must still reach the minimum wage. Many restaurants keep it simple and pay trial shifts at a flat hourly rate with no tip credit.

Federal minimum for tipped employees: cash wage plus maximum tip creditFederal floor of $7.25 an hour; many states require more
Federal minimum for tipped employees: cash wage plus maximum tip creditStacked bar chart. Minimum cash wage: $2.13; Maximum tip credit: $5.12.Minimum cash wage: $2.13 (29%)Maximum tip credit: $5.12 (71%)Federal minimum for tipped employees: cash wage plus maximum tip creditStacked bar chart. Minimum cash wage: $2.13; Maximum tip credit: $5.12.Minimum cash wage: $2.13 (29%)Maximum tip credit: $5.12 (71%)
  • Minimum cash wage $2.13 29%
  • Maximum tip credit $5.12 71%

Source: US Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division, 2026[6]

Show the data
ItemValue
Minimum cash wage$2.13
Maximum tip credit$5.12

Any tips the candidate earns belong to them. Federal law bars employers from keeping employees' tips for any purpose, including letting managers or supervisors keep a share[3]. If your restaurant pools tips, decide in advance how a trial worker is included and pay them out with their wages.

Run a paid working interview properly

  1. Decide the length

    Two to four hours is enough to see skill; longer trials add little and look like free labor even when paid.

  2. Tell the candidate in writing

    State that the working interview is paid, the hourly rate, the date, the time and what to bring.

  3. Set up payroll

    Treat the person as a short-term employee in your payroll system, with the forms your provider requires, including Form I-9. Employers must complete Section 2 of Form I-9 within 3 business days of the date of hire[7]; check the earlier deadline for very short engagements.

  4. Supervise and score

    Pair them with a lead and use a fixed scorecard, so the trial is a fair test rather than a free extra pair of hands.

  5. Pay on your normal cycle

    Pay through payroll with a pay stub, on the next regular payday or sooner. Avoid cash.

For what to put in the trial itself, see line cook interview questions and stages and interview questions for restaurant servers.

What it costs, and what it saves

Example: a three-hour stage for a line cook at $18 an hour costs $54 plus employer payroll taxes. Two paid trials per opening cost little more than $100, a small amount against the cost of hiring the wrong person, training them and starting again a few weeks later.

The risks of not paying are larger than the savings. A former candidate can file a wage claim with the Department of Labor or a state agency, and an investigation can look at other pay practices at the same time. Unpaid trials also hurt your reputation among local cooks and servers, who share stories about which kitchens treat people fairly.

There is a quality benefit too. When a trial is paid and planned, managers prepare real tasks, assign a lead to work alongside the candidate and fill in a scorecard. Unpaid trials tend to be improvised: the candidate is dropped onto a busy station and judged on a chaotic night. Paying for the hours makes the test fairer and the decision better.

Edge cases to think about

  • The candidate offers to work for free: accepting is still risky. The law does not let employees waive minimum wage.
  • The candidate is still employed elsewhere: that does not change your obligation to pay for the hours they work for you.
  • The trial runs into overtime for a candidate who already works for you in another role: hours across roles add up.
  • The candidate is under 18: check federal and state youth employment rules on hours and tasks before you schedule a trial.
  • You are a franchisee: your franchise system may have its own policy; follow the stricter of that policy and the law.

If you have run unpaid trials before

Many restaurants discover the problem only after years of unpaid stages. Start by changing the practice today: tell every manager that from now on all working interviews are paid, and update your hiring checklist and job post templates.

Then look back. List recent trial shifts you can identify from schedules, messages or notes, with the hours worked. Talk to an employment adviser about whether to pay those hours now; paying voluntarily is often simpler than responding to a claim, and it is the fair outcome for the people who worked. Keep a record of what you paid and why. Finally, tell your team what changed. Cooks and servers who did unpaid stages themselves will notice, and a kitchen known for paying every hour is easier to hire into.

A checklist for owners

  • Write a short policy: all working interviews are paid at the role's rate, for every hour.
  • Keep unpaid steps to a conversation and a tour.
  • Put the trial worker on payroll and keep records of hours.
  • Pay trial workers their tips.
  • Train managers on the policy, especially in the kitchen where the stage tradition is strongest.
  • Review the policy with an employment adviser in each state where you operate.

Paid trials also make your hiring better. Candidates take them more seriously, managers plan them properly and you can say honestly in your job posts that every working interview is paid. See how to hire restaurant staff fast for the full process and how to retain restaurant employees for what happens after the offer.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to pay someone for a trial shift?

Generally yes. If the person does productive work for your restaurant, the time is work time under the FLSA and must be paid at least the applicable minimum wage. State and local rules may require more.

Is an unpaid stage legal for line cooks?

An unpaid stage where the cook preps or cooks for service is generally not compliant with federal wage law. Pay the stage at the role's rate and keep only the interview conversation unpaid.

Can a server keep tips from a trial shift?

Yes. Tips belong to the employee, and federal law bars employers from keeping them. Include the trial worker in the tip pool according to your written pool rules.

How long should a paid trial shift be?

Two to four hours is usually enough to see skill and fit. Longer trials add little and can look like using candidates as extra labor.

References

  1. US Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division (2008). Fact Sheet #22: Hours Worked Under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Information Institute (Cornell Law School), US Code (2026). 29 U.S. Code § 206 - Minimum wage (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Information Institute (Cornell Law School), US Code (2026). 29 U.S. Code § 203 - Definitions (Fair Labor Standards Act) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Information Institute (Cornell Law School), eCFR text (2026). 29 CFR 785.11: General (work suffered or permitted) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. California Department of Industrial Relations, Labor Commissioner's Office (2024). Fast Food Minimum Wage FAQ (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. US Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division (2026). Minimum Wages for Tipped Employees (state and federal table) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. US Citizenship and Immigration Services (2026). Completing Section 2, Employer Review and Attestation (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo